On 8/17/2016 13:10, Brandt, Riley wrote:
> I am also experiencing disappointing performance in darktable on a new
> Macbook Pro. Same model as yours I believe:
> 
> Mid 2015, 2.5 GHz Intel i7
> 16 GB Ram
> Intel Iris Pro
> AMD Radeon R9 M370X – 2 GB Ram
> 
> When you enable OpenCL, and open an image in the darkroom module,
> doesn't it turn the photos green? It does on mine. There is a known bug:
> https://redmine.darktable.org/issues/10274

Hey Riley, good to hear from you again!

Sounds like we have basically the same machine. I have the issue with
the green photos too (Rafa García was just telling me about it off
list). Our MBP model does have the dedicated Radeon M370X card but it
seems Darktable doesn't cause the OS to automatically switch, at least
on mine.

On that tangent I also just discovered that the person who writes
gfxCarStatus has updated their application to work with newer versions
of OS X. It's a little menubar widget that lets you override the OS and
manually force the dedicated card into service. I'm going to give that a
go and see if forcing Darktable to use the Radeon helps any. You may
want to give it a shot too: https://gfx.io/

> Do you experience this at all? Or just in the lighttable module?

Mostly just the lighttable module, but I'm a pretty light editor
honestly. More than a few minutes in the Darktable module and the image
goes in the garbage. :) I was the same way in Lightroom. I'll spend
three hours getting things lined up in real life instead of spending
five minutes in post. If I did use more than a few masks the darkroom
module did slow down tremendously. I'd get the beach ball trying to
switch back out into the lighttable module, menus wouldn't respond, etc.
So yes I did notice that too.

> I was expecting a big performance increase from my older 2012 Macbook
> Pro, but that hasn't really been the case.

I came from a 2011 MBP (2.3Ghz Sandy Bridge i7/16GB/512GB SSD/6770) and
wasn't expecting more than a marginal to OK speed increase. The 2.0.5
update hit before my new machine arrived so I just attributed the slow
down to old hardware. After the new machine failed to move any faster at
all I became a bit more concerned.

For now I've downgraded back to 2.0.4 and things are moving along
better. Still not near as speedy as the desktop Linux machine but there
is a large CPU/GPU/RAM gap between the two so that's probably some of
it. I'm tempted fire up my old Mac Pro, upgrade the graphics card and
slap a relatively cheap SSD in it to see what it'll do. There probably
aren't as many Mac users with Darktable as Linux so I imagine all data
from as many hardware configs as they can get will be helpful. Not to
mention winter is coming and I can use that thing to heat the house! ;)

Thanks again!

Leander



____________________________________________________________________________
darktable user mailing list
to unsubscribe send a mail to [email protected]

Reply via email to