Hi Guys,
@Jack - yes - baseline is disabled for filmic
@David - I did not use preset in filmic. If I turn preserve crominance -
the results become even worse (pink)
@Remco - I just tried 15EV preset and extreme luminance about 50% -
still very different. I take the point for clipped data but the effect
is overall - the complete image is affected - not only the over exposed.
Besides - this is just a sample. I am observing the same in images that
have no clipped areas.
Honestly... the color difference basecurve vs filmic is so dramatic to
me that is *forbidding* the use of the module in a significant amount of
images for me. I am perplexed as "why" the color is so different. Tried
to export the images and the effect is persistent in Geeqie.
Regards,
B
On 2019-04-09 00:27, Remco Viëtor wrote:
On mardi 9 avril 2019 06:25:36 CEST I. Ivanov wrote:
Hi Guys,
I have tried to use the filmic module.
I am very confused at the coloring filmic is giving me - much redder
images and reduces the yellow tones.
https://www.dropbox.com/s/p7kvfgm7vggzey1/20150323_060922_9296.CR2?dl=0
https://www.dropbox.com/s/8enxw2mptakh9bb/20150323_060922_9296_01.CR2.xmp?dl
=0
https://www.dropbox.com/s/c9muec00sjeyw2k/20150323_060922_9296.CR2.xmp?dl=0
It is possible to change the image of course with color correction or
something else. But when I compare filmic vs basecurve - the basecurve
gives me a color very close to the naturally scene while the filmic
looks much redder to me and it is also loosing the yellow hues seen in
the golden hour.
Just a quick look, but I had to reduce the exposure by about 1 EV (Exposure
module), and with the 15EV preset in "filmic" increase the 'extreme luminance
saturation' to about 50%. You will still get differences wrt the standard
basecurve.
It looks like the reds are over-exposed (clipped in the raw data), so hard to
get something realistic out of it as you are missing data.
Remco
____________________________________________________________________________
darktable user mailing list
to unsubscribe send a mail to [email protected]
____________________________________________________________________________
darktable user mailing list
to unsubscribe send a mail to [email protected]
