"this one may be arguable, but it seems evident to me after seeing
video and audio, and some interviews, that the Stephen opener is not
cut on the recordings, but was actually played that way - they just
abandoned it early on."

Pardon the delayed response. I also think they just bailed, as on the tape.

Though deadlists says there's an edit at 1:25, it's not apparent -
there are some mix changes, as usual for the first song in a set.  
But strangely, the second verse is skipped - and with two singers,
that would be difficult to do.

The video is also useful - unfortunately, I can't find a video that
shows the actual segue, but this is the Stephen:
<http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drBPBUFnQAk>
And Mama Tried, from the same camera: 
<http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-eYnn6TufdU>
(Notice that Bob & Phil are in exactly the same spot when Mama Tried
starts as when Stephen ends, suggesting it is continuous.)

I don't see an edit in the Stephen video either - BUT, there is a
discrepancy.  Compare the little guitar break between the two
verses. It's different on the tape vs. the video.  So it seems like
there has to be an edit (perhaps the second verse was snipped) -
though the video looks like an unbroken shot.

One of the 8/16/69 files on the Archive notes, "there seem to be
disguised splices in St. Stephen... It seems possible that power was
cutting out at times causing this problem."   So, if the second verse
got neatly spliced out, perhaps the second half of the song did
too....

But my feeling is that the Stephen>Mama Tried segue went down the way
we hear it. The videos certainly look that way.  The band was quite
confused at the show, and I think they realized after a couple minutes
that Stephen was going to be a mess, and decided to switch to
something simpler.

The Stephen>Mama Tried segue is unique to this show. It does seem
fishy, but heck, it adds to the Woodstock mystique: "the show so bad
they couldn't even finish St Stephen!"  On the other hand, if we
speculate that some tricky edit took out the second half of Stephen,
we have to ask - how did the song end?  Stephen never just ended, it
always segued. In 1969, it nearly always went into the Eleven. (A
couple times it went into Lovelight.) There's no way that happened at
Woodstock.  If they didn't segue into Mama Tried, the song likely
collapsed into a complete trainwreck (or perhaps the power went out
altogether), which may be why that part would be edited out. 

Take your pick!

  • 8/16/69 Nicholas A. Brush
    • Re: 8/16/69 Caleb Kennedy

Reply via email to