On 2013-07-20 20:32 , Maurizio Avogadro wrote:
> This makes the init script useless for NetworkManager users; by adding
> to it the LSB headers
> 
> Should-Start: network-manager

This sounds like something sane to do.

> Should-Stop:  network-manager

This does not entirely; stopping AICCU (thus giving up IPv6
connectivity) does not always mean you want to disconnect everything,
there are networks where even AYIYA won't get out of.


That said, tinc might benefit from the Should-Start addition too.
OpenVPN already has this setup.

[..]
> The soft dependency should leave the behaviorunchangedfor non-NM users;
> since the connection is established only once at startup, this behavior
> should be compatible with the strict policiesenforced by SixXS, which
> forbid automatic reconnections.

Nothing strict about this policy, just think about if you would like it
if your servers where connected to in a never ending repeating loop (at
the rates of hundreds of connects per second from what we have seen)
where the user of that automated restart does not realize that that is
happening as something in the background is doing it; or because they
think they are ubersmart and monitored some random unrelated thing on
the Internet and think that restarting is needed...

Please note that the policy is primarily there to protect the server
from being overwhelmed with useless requests that would effectively also
cause a DoS for other users of that service. The behaviour of too many
restarts also indicates that the source of those requests is having a
problem that should be properly resolved.

Greets,
 Jeroen


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-bugs-dist-requ...@lists.debian.org
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org

Reply via email to