Ross Boylan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> README.Debian says
> "$DUMP_DIR should be on a large partition; one with enough free space to
> hold all of your dumped backups."
> 
> Install.html says
> "Since the PORT-WRITE command is now supported you no longer need to
> configure a holding disk."
> 
> (Note I'm assuming, perhaps incorrectly, that the "holding disk" and
> the $DUMP_DIR are the same thing.)

They're not. Amanda has the concept of a "holding disk", where it spools
your backups before writing them to tape. You can instead have it write
them directly to CDRW-Taper, which needs its own place to store stuff
until it has enough to write a CD. That place is $DUMP_DIR.

> Overview.html says
> "The idea is to have the taper copy the backed up data to several
> intermediate directories, each representing a single CDRW. After the
> backup is finished, these can be burnt to CDRW one by one. "

The first disk can be burnt as soon as it's ready. The rest have to be
stored on the disk until a human (or trained monkey) can physically
change CDs and burn some more. There is supposedly some support for disk
changers, just incase you have one, but I don't think it's tested.

> All this leaves me thoroughly confused about whether I need to have
> disk space sufficient to hold my entire backup at once or not.  This
> is probably the difference between something that is feasible or not
> for me.

You will need approximately enough space to hold (entire backup - one
CD/DVD).

> I'm interested in backing up to multiple CD's.  Unfortunately,
> Install.html is filled with lots of warnings that the relevant
> functionality (including PORT-WRITE) is alpha.

I have successfully had CDRW-Taper automatically burning the first disc
of a backup run, but I wouldn't call it well tested. I had to fix a few
bugs to make it work and I may not have gotten them all.

> The authors of this package might want to look at, or even use,
> cdbackup, which has multi-volume capability.

The (upstream) authors of this package don't seem to care about it
anymore. I'm personally using bacula these days, not CDRW-Taper, and I'm
looking for someone to take over the package. I can sponsor uploads.

> P.S. I'd think amanda-cdrw-taper would be a better name for this
> package.

This is possibly true, but probably not worth the trouble of changing
it.
-- 
Sam "Eddie" Couter  |  mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Debian Developer    |  mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
                    |  jabber:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
OpenPGP fingerprint:  A46B 9BB5 3148 7BEA 1F05  5BD5 8530 03AE DE89 C75C

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Reply via email to