A "grave" bug is one serious enough to prevent the release of the
package.  The description of this priority (in bug-maint-info.txt)
does mention "data loss" as a possible justification for marking a bug
as grave, but the data loss described in this bug report (qualified as
"minor" in the submitter's justification tag) is not of sufficient
seriousness that users would prefer not to have the package at all
compared to having the package with this bug.

(Indeed, I'd question whether it even merits "important" severity, i.e.
 I don't think the bug "has a major effect on the usability of [the]
 package": (i) I haven't managed to reproduce this bug in 0.42.2-1, and
 previous comments here mention difficulty in reproducing.  (ii) At
 least two work-arounds exist, namely to edit the text in-line (if I've
 correctly understood from the original bug report) or to use the XML
 editor.  (iii) I'm not sure I've seen this bug reported before in the
 bug tracker or on #inkscape, so I suppose it's not a major problem for
 most people.  Indeed, I'd say most SVG files don't even contain text;
 text editing is not a major part of inkscape use, which suggests that
 most text-editing bugs don't have "a major effect on [usability]".)

So first of all, please reduce the severity (I'd suggest "normal"),
which will allow inkscape 0.43 to enter testing, which in turn might
make it easier for some people to confirm whether the bug is still in
0.43-1 or not.  (At least one bug related to line-spacing has been fixed
upstream between 0.42 and 0.43.)

Can someone report on their experiences reproduce this on 0.43-1 ?  (I
haven't managed to reproduce the bug even in the version where this bug
was originally reported (0.42.2-1).)  If you can reproduce it, then
please attach an example file and steps of how to reproduce the bug, to
assist in fixing the bug.  I believe Debian's 0.43-1 isn't very heavily
patched relative to upstream, so I'd guess that the bug isn't
Debian-specific; so you might consider reporting the bug upstream: see
the "Bug reports" link on the left of http://inkscape.org/.

pjrm.


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to