Package: ftp.debian.org
Severity: normal

Hi,

I am trying to do a source-only upload [1] of the new rustc. I prefer to do
source-only uploads because I like to have the buildds rebuild my amd64
packages, for safety and security. Other reasons are documented on that page.

With every new version of rustc, we have a new libstd-rust-$version binary
package. This causes every upload to be added to NEW, which triggers the "no
source-only uploads" rule, causing my upload to be REJECTED. IMO this is a bit
pointless - the binary:NEW is not really a significant change, and if I wanted
to "game the system" there are plenty of things I could do whilst keeping the
binary package names the same. I can understand ftp-master wanting to do a
manual audit regardless, but to turn this into an automatic REJECT simply
because I didn't supply binary packages that I built myself, is inconvenient
and defeats the purpose of the SourceOnlyUpload feature.

X

[1] https://wiki.debian.org/SourceOnlyUpload

Reply via email to