Hello Christian!

Thank you for doing this.

17.02.2017 13:48, Christian Ehrhardt wrote:

> case   sha1         summary
> a      84dc4d05d3   ubuntu acl fix dependencies changed

This really should be fixed in acl package, not in qemu.  I
filed a bugreport about this quite some time ago, and actually
forgot about it.

> a      0d52ac1285   Make qemu-system-common depend on qemu-block-extra
> a      b24146b825   Make qemu-utils depend on qemu-block-extra

This is something I really don't want to do. This completely
defeats the purpose of qemu-block-extra package.

The idea was to be able to ship less commonly used backends
in a separate package to avoid too much dependencies.
When you make these a strong dependency, you end up always
installing this package.

I objected when this has been done in Ubuntu, and asked for
a reason for this, but never seen a reply.  Maybe you can
re-evaluate the reasons why this has been made in Ubuntu,
and revert this change.

I can _guess_ this was because some people complained that
after introducing this new qemu-block-extra package, their
block devices stopped working (because they've been moved
to -extra out of main). We can't really deal with this by
introducing new packages and making transitional packages,
we can, however, _recommend_ the new package, and we can
mention this in the NEWS file (both of which I did).

> a      5dea4321d9   qemu-efi is in universe
> a      4018ada7da   no more skip enable libiscsi (now in main)
> a      fc0aef8d0c   let qemu-utils recommend sharutils
> b      a06832a485   avoid people editing d/control
> b      7a257a6a46   Enable seccomp for ppc64el
> a      5c4d2d0849   Disable glusterfs (Universe dependency)
> b      78aaa8e6b0   char: fix ctrl-a b not working
> b      4aa3e058c2   bump libseccomp-dev dependency

The rest is good small fixes.  78aaa8e6b0 is from upstream and
should be in next their stable, hopefully.  These are good small
changes I'll definitely pick.

At any rate, all this, unfortunately, is post-stretch matherial,
as I can't change anything in the main branch at this time,
unfortunately.  Maybe it's time to create debian-stretch
branch anyway.

Thank you very much!

/mjt

Reply via email to