Resend with correct BTS address. Am 09.09.18 um 09:41 schrieb Carsten Schoenert: > Control: retitle -1 OAuth2 does seems not work with TB 60 > Control: tag -1 unreproducible > > Please avoid top posting, it's difficult to understand and to read. I > need to keep now the original email as is so other people can follow > this report on the BTS. > Also please use "Reply All" so the BTS is updated as well. > > Am 08.09.18 um 22:21 schrieb Benjamin Redelings: >> Thanks for following up. >> >> Third followup: I've attached the log you mentioned for a successful >> login (good.log) and a failed login (bad.log), with my e-mail address >> removed. >> >> The working login is with Debian version 52.9.1-1. The failed login is >> with an official 60.0, downloaded Sep 5, although the files seem to be >> from Jul 31. There is no change between the configurations -- I just >> closed 0.52.9 and immediately opened 60.0. Apparmor is not installed. >> >> Version 60.0 gives the same failure messages as the Debian version. >> Using an official download for version 60 and allows me to easily switch >> between versions without uninstalling the working Debian version. > > We didn't have modified anything within the source that is slightly > involved in any way. > I'm just using plain SSL/TLS + password to authenticate against GMail > for years. I never had any problem. And even if I now switch to OAuth2 > in my profile it works also without problems. > > Also given we would really have some problem here I guess we would have > a lot more reports with complaining users given the wide usage of the > GMail service. So currently I simply can't believe there should be > something broken. > > I now tried to reproduce the problem on a complete new user profile with > than an also complete new Thunderbird profile. I was able to to do the > GMail setup without any interruption within one go! Given you know your > main GMail password. I can't reproduce the described behavior here. > > The created new GMail profile is even taken OAuth2 as the default > authentication method! So I hardly believe you must do $something wrong > on your side while you create a new GMail account setting. > > Please check the password you are using is really valid, people mainly > mismatch the master password with the application tokens. OAuth2 is a > multi factor authentication, if the first step isn't working the chain > afterwards can't work. > >> I think you can tell this from the log, but I'm using SSL/TLS with >> OAUTH2. My gmail setting do allow insecure apps, but since I'm logging >> in with OAUTH, I'm not sure this makes a difference. >> >> I'm not sure this log gives a lot of details about what is different >> between the successful and failed logins ... what next? >> >> -BenRI >> >> P.S. yes, it does appear that this is an upstream problem >> >> On 09/08/2018 04:34 AM, Carsten Schoenert wrote: >>> Control: tag -1 moreinfo >>> >>> Hello Benjamin, >>> >>> On Wed, Sep 05, 2018 at 08:45:30AM -0400, Benjamin Redelings wrote: >>>> First followup: this problem DOES exist with the upstream tarball. >>>> >>>> Authentication failure connecting to imap.gmail.com >>>> <http://imap.gmail.com>, I think. >>>> Second followup: the problem still persists if I remove apparmor. >>>> >>>> Authentication failure contacting server imap.gmail.com >>>> <http://imap.gmail.com> >>> your information is a bit poor. >>> Your first answer is saying the problem also exists with the Mozilla >>> upstream binaries. This says to me it's nearly not Debian faults that >>> your connection does not work. >>> >>> OTOH we don't know what you have excately done. >>> What are your settings you use to connect to GMail? >>> What logs do you excately get? (Be aware you need to cut off personal >>> information probably). >>> >>> We have quit no info what's going on your side so we can't really help. >>> >>> https://support.google.com/mail/answer/7126229?visit_id=636719921179224568-346459646&rd=1 >>> https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/thunderbird-and-gmail >>> >>> For debugging of the Thunderbird communication to the email server you >>> will need to start Thunderbird from the command line. >>> >>> $ NSPR_LOG_MODULES=IMAP:5,SMTP:5 LANG= thunderbird >>> >>> Regards >>> Carsten >> >
-- Mit freundlichen Grüßen Carsten Schönert
