Is there any chance of a way forward on this?

It seems that the drivedb.h updates in the 'smartmontools' package aren't just 
slow, but non-existent - the version that ships with Debian 9.7 dates from a 
year *before* the release of Debian 9.0

If there is no script to perform an update in the package, and the version 
available with Debian is ancient, then you end up in a worse situation than 
what you are trying to avoid - users (like me just now) end up downloading 
unsigned and unchecked versions of drivedb.h from the Internet by hand, and 
manually applying them to their systems - I think that is much likely to end up 
with system breakages than having at least some directions to a (semi-secure) 
script that will do it correctly.

It also seems that almost 3 years after the problem was first mentioned 
online(in a Ubuntu bug report comment), the man page for "update-smart-drivedb" 
is still in Debian, despite the script having been removed. I would personally 
suggest that rather than removing the manual page completely, it should be 
replaced with a page describing that the script has been removed from Debian, 
and what users should do instead.

Reply via email to