Package: knot-host
Version: 2.7.6-2
Severity: normal

I am on Buster 10.0.

The knot-host package provides the 'host' command, or at least so
says the package's own description. However, bug #741645 for
knot-dnsutils (which was also applied to knot-host) was submitted
a couple years ago about conflicts with the 'host', 'dig' and 'nsupdate'
commands that are provided by the dnsutils and bind9-host packages.

That bug concluded with removing the conflicting commands from
the knot packages with the mention that update-alternatives seems
the better option, which I agree is a reasonable solution.  Problem
is the knot-host and knot-dnsutils packages never actually had any
update-alternatives configuration added to them.  They therefore no
longer provide the 'host', 'dig', or 'nsupdate' commands that their
package descriptions claim they do, at least not under those
specific command names.

I'm using these packages to provide those commands.  The change
didn't impact me until Debian Buster (Stretch's version didn't have
this change applied), so once I upgraded dists I noticed, otherwise
I would've commented on the earlier bug report and change
considerably sooner.

Basically, the knot-host and knot-dnsutils packages should provide
update-alternatives functionality, and that is the purpose of this bug
report, which should be applied to both packages.  Through this
method they would provide the 'host', 'dig' and 'nsupdate' commands
they previously did.  Yes I can set that up manually, but I shouldn't
have to.  These packages should have the alternatives functionality
included.

Thank you.

Reply via email to