Package: ftp.debian.org
Severity: normal

Hi,

I'm hereby requesting removal of libgtk2-perl, as one of its maintainers,
and of its remaining 4 reverse-dependencies, as the last step of a plan
that was communicated to the relevant maintainers years ago.

The reverse-dependencies covered by this request are: asciio,
libcircle-fe-gtk-perl, libdata-treedumper-renderer-gtk-perl,
and tinyca.

In November 2018:

 - The Debian GNOME team announced¹ their larger effort to reduce gtk2 use as
   much as possible in Debian, including "For Bullseye, we are serious about our
   intention to remove […] libgtk2-perl".

 - I proposed² a plan to remove libgtk2-perl from Debian and filed bug reports
   against all reverse-dependencies.

In July 2019 these bug reports were made RC.

In October 2019, libgtk2-perl was removed from testing.

In January 2021, Dominic Hargreaves and I discussed this topic³. We agreed to
give the maintainers of the reverse-dependencies a last chance to get their
package in Bullseye before migration of new source packages to testing is
disabled (2021-02-12), and then to remove libgtk2-perl and its remaining
reverse-dependencies from sid at any time after 2021-02-12.

We've now reached this point and I think it's time to proceed with the removal:
the maintainers of the remaining reverse-dependencies have now had between 20
and 28 months to port their package to GTK3, or ask upstream to.

Here's a summary of the status of these reverse-dependencies:

 - asciio (#912870): bug not marked as forwarded upstream; I filed a RFH in
   August 2020, nobody volunteered; last upstream release in 2015;
   popcon votes = 12

 - libcircle-fe-gtk-perl (#932220): bug not marked as forwarded upstream;
   uploaded after the removal plan was announced, never reached testing;
   last upstream release in 2017; popcon votes = 0

 - libdata-treedumper-renderer-gtk-perl (#912874): bug not marked as forwarded
   upstream; no upstream activity since at least 2016; popcon votes = 12
   (which matches asciio, it's only reverse-dependency)

 - tinyca (#912889): bug not marked as forwarded upstream; upstream homepage
   lost since Alioth was shut down; porting work started in September 2020, no
   news since then; popcon votes = 59

Please let me know if you'd like me to take extra steps in order
to get these packages removed, since I don't maintain them myself.

[1] https://lists.debian.org/debian-devel/2018/11/msg00570.html
[2] https://bugs.debian.org/912860
[3] https://bugs.debian.org/942135#91

Cheers!

Reply via email to