Control: tag -1 + moreinfo
01.05.2022 14:59, John Shaft wrote:
Package: ldnsutils
Version: 1.8.1-1
Severity: wishlist
Dear Maintainer,
ldns 1.8.0 introduced support for SVCB & HTTPS resource records [1],[2]
It has to be compiled via a specific parameter --enable-rrtype-svcb-https
Could the debian package be shipped with this option enabled ?
From ldns's ./configure --help:
--enable-rrtype-ninfo Enable draft RR type ninfo.
--enable-rrtype-rkey Enable draft RR type rkey.
--disable-rrtype-openpgpkey
Disable openpgpkey RR type.
--enable-rrtype-ta Enable draft RR type ta.
--enable-rrtype-avc Enable draft RR type avc.
--enable-rrtype-doa Enable draft RR type DOA.
--enable-rrtype-amtrelay
Enable draft RR type AMTRELAY.
--enable-rrtype-svcb-https
Enable draft RR types SVCB and HTTPS.
Neither of these is enabled.
I wonder if we should enable them all.
I don't see any special dependencies for these, it just
an ifdef in rr.c:
#ifdef RRTYPE_SVCB_HTTPS
static const ldns_rdf_type type_svcb_wireformat[] = {
LDNS_RDF_TYPE_INT16,
LDNS_RDF_TYPE_DNAME,
LDNS_RDF_TYPE_SVCPARAMS
};
#endif
#ifdef RRTYPE_SVCB_HTTPS
/* 64 */
{LDNS_RR_TYPE_SVCB, "SVCB", 2, 3, type_svcb_wireformat,
LDNS_RDF_TYPE_NONE, LDNS_RR_NO_COMPRESS, 0 },
/* 65 */
{LDNS_RR_TYPE_HTTPS, "HTTPS", 2, 3, type_svcb_wireformat,
LDNS_RDF_TYPE_NONE, LDNS_RR_NO_COMPRESS, 0 },
#else
{LDNS_RR_TYPE_NULL, "TYPE64", 1, 1, type_0_wireformat, LDNS_RDF_TYPE_NONE,
LDNS_RR_NO_COMPRESS, 0 },
{LDNS_RR_TYPE_NULL, "TYPE65", 1, 1, type_0_wireformat, LDNS_RDF_TYPE_NONE,
LDNS_RR_NO_COMPRESS, 0 },
#endif
I wonder why they didn't enable them. If the reason is that these
are DRAFTs, - maybe it's okay to use DRAFT-HTTPS instead of HTTPS there?
Ondřej, do you have any comments about these?
Thanks,
/mjt
