> Would you be willing to add support for search domains, but turn it
> off by default?  Would you accept a patch that did so?

You've convinced me.  Yes, I would.

>> 2. I'm opposed to using domain search paths, and I'm a stubborn bastard.

> I'd like to know WHY you're opposed to them,

Because they break the main desirable property of names: location
independence.

In a computer network, we have three kinds of locators/identifiers:

  - routes;
  - addresses;
  - names.

Addresses and names are localtion-independent: at a given point in time,
huponomos.wifi.pps.jussieu.fr refers to exactly the same machine for
everyone in the universe.

In the past, people confused names and routes; for example, UUCP used
routes instead of names in e-mail addresses.  You'd end up saying silly
things like « if you're at Berkeley, my e-mail address is..., but if
you're at Bell Labs, it's... ».

Search paths break the location-independence of names.

                                        Juliusz




--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-bugs-dist-requ...@lists.debian.org
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org

Reply via email to