* David Stansby <[email protected]> [20090813 11:16]:

> I'm filing this bug to call for the removal of ddrescue from debian. This is
> for the following reasons:

> 1. ddrescue contains dd_rescue, whereas gddrescue contains dd_rescue and
> dd_rhelp, so gddrescue has superseeded ddrescue

gddrescue: /sbin/ddrescue
ddrescue:  /bin/dd_rescue

I don't find dd_rhelp anywhere.

> 2. ddrescue has not been updated for over two years now, and is no longer in
> active development, whereas gddrescue is

I plan to NMU the ddrescue package.

(And if Ayman Negm doesn't have any objections I'd volunteer in
taking over maintenance.)

> 3. There is some confusion over the naming of these two packages, and I
> belive that removing ddrescue will go some way to alleviating this confusion

Yeah, I think we could improve the package descriptions so it's more
obvious what you'll get.

Though I don't want to see ddrescue disapear from Debian.
It supports a few options that I don't find in gddrescue yet,
namely being:

       -r     reverse direction copy (default=forward)
       -w     abort on Write errors (default=no)
       -a     spArse file writing (default=no)
       -A     Always write blocks, zeroed if err (default=no)
       -i     interactive: ask before overwriting data (default=no)
       -f     force: skip some sanity checks (default=no)

regards,
-mika-

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Reply via email to