hi Henrique,

On Sun, Nov 09, 2025 at 06:14:23PM -0300, Henrique de Moraes Holschuh wrote:
> AMD changes to avoid regressing outdated family 19h systems have
> showed up on linux-firmware recently, and there are patches to the
> kernel microcode driver on their way to mainline (they can be seen
> on the "tip" tree).
> 
> I am packaging the new microcode update to upload to *unstable*, but
> systems with outdated firmware are supposed to regress unless they
> also have the kernel changes, so updates to stable are still in the
> future.
> 
> It has also become very clear that:
> 
> 1. Family 0x19 (Zen 2 to Zen 4) will have the choice of staying on
> the last Entrysign-vulnerable microcode release.  Obviously, they
> will remain vulnerable to Entrysign and everything else fixed since
> Entrysign, since they will *not* receive any new microcode updates.
> 
> 2. Zen 5 systems have no such choice: all systems must update the
> firmware to fix Entrysign in order to receive microcode updates.
> 
> We can issue partial security updates to stable covering only family
> 0x1a (Zen 5) while we wait for the kernel-side changes that will
> enable us to ship the fixes for family 0x19 without regressing
> systems with outdated firmware.

I pondered your mail for a while now.

I think there is no urgency to do a partial update and we can look
forward if and when the changes will trickle into stable series
upstream (if at all). The relevant series for the changes only entered
v6.19-rc1 so far.

In particular as the older back we go, Zen 5 Linux support get less
relevant, so it does make less sense to issue updates with only that
part, well maybe as stable-proposed-update indeed for trixie and
6.12.y based kernel but not older (not considering backports kernel).

Regards,
Salvatore

Reply via email to