And now the final tally. I had meant, in my mail from brazil, that the vote on
the constitution should be considred passed since the outcome was "not in
doubt" and I would have/could have terminated the vote period early had I
gotten net access sooner. The old figures were 80 votes for and 0 votes
against the constitution with 11 votes in doubt. Even if all eleven votes were
negative, YES would still have dominated all other options AND have gotten the
required number of votes above..
I still have 6000+ pieces of email to sort though so it'll be a few days before
I get all the ballots somewhere where they can be gotten to by anyone who
wishes. I don't want that lack, however, to be the hold up for getting the
Tech-Commitee and other parts of the constitution going.
constitution results - 86 valid votes
YES has:
86 1st preference votes
0 2nd preference votes
0 3rd preference votes
0 no preference votes
NO has:
0 1st preference votes
5 2nd preference votes
27 3rd preference votes
54 no preference votes
FURTHER DISCUSSION has:
0 1st preference votes
58 2nd preference votes
5 3rd preference votes
23 no preference votes
YES
Dominates NO [86 - 0]
Dominates FURTHER DISCUSSION [86 - 0]
NO
FURTHER DISCUSSION
Dominates NO [58 - 5]
"YES" wins by dominating all others.
constitution Final Vote Ack
FURTHER DISCUSSION -----+
NO ----+|
YES ---+||
|||
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Stephan Alexander Suerken 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] A. P. Harris 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Adam Klein
1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Andrew Howell 132
Anthony 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Ardo van Rangelrooij 123
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Alen Zekulic 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Craig Sanders
1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Petr CECH 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Juan Cespedes 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Christian Hudon 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Christophe Le Bars 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Daniel Jacobowitz
1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Richard Braakman
132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] David Frey 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Chris G. Davis 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] David Huggins-Daines
132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Dima Barsky 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Yann Dirson 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] James LewisMoss 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Dale Scheetz 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Dirk Eddelbuettel 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Robert S. Edmonds 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Mark W. Eichin 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Joel Klecker 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Enrique Zanardi 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Francesco Tapparo 123
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Daniel Martin 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Frederic Peters 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Darren Benham 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Herbert Xu 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Hugo Haas 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Bob Hilliard 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Ian Jackson 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Anders
Hammarquist 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] James Troup 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Jakob Borg 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] J.H.M. Dassen (Ray) 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Jens Ritter 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Javier Fernandez-Sanguino Pen~a 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Jason Gunthorpe 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Jim Pick 123
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Jim Mintha 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Joel Rosdahl 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Johnie Ingram 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Eric Leblanc 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Kai Henningsen
1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Kirk Hilliard 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Joseph Carter 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Christian Leutloff 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Paolo Molaro 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Guy Maor 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Martin Buck 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Martin Mitchell 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Martin Bialasinski 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Marcelo E. Magallon 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Hamish Moffatt 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Raul Miller 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Nils Rennebarth 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Oliver Elphick 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Milan Zamazal
1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Ben Pfaff 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Philipp Frauenfelder 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Marco Pistore 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Peter Van Eynde 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Christopher N. Lawrence 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Rafael Laboissiere 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Robert Woodcock
132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Remco van de Meent 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Raphael Hertzog 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Ruud de Rooij 123
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Davide G. M. Salvetti
1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Santiago Vila Doncel 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sean E. Perry 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Scott Hanson 132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Stephen J. Carpenter
132
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Manoj Srivastava 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Stig Sandbeck Mathisen
123
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Steve Greenland 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Tom Lees
1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Tom Lear 1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Darren/Torin/Who Ever...
1-2
[EMAIL PROTECTED] James A. Treacy 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Wichert Akkerman 1--
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Zed Pobre 1-2
Votes in error
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Erik Andersen
! No vote statement in message
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Bdale
Garbee
! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Mark
Baker
! Bad PGP or not PGP signed
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Michael Meskes
! No vote statement in message
