Hi Nicolas,
On Wed, 11 Nov 2026, Nicolas Schier wrote:
>
> On Mon, Nov 09, 2026 at 02:18:49PM +0100, Ahmed S. Darwish wrote:
> >
> > This is why one of the development rules at the top of the Python script,
> > at patch 03/10, is:
> >
> > The tool must not depend on being run inside the kernel source tree.
> > This simplifies invocation, testing and possible future packaging.
>
> Then, please move the argument checking from Makefile to the script
> itself. Handling wrong arguments is good native feature for the script.
>
The script does its own argument checking, all through Python's native
argparse mechanism:
$ ./tools/kconfig-checker/check.py check -h
usage: check.py check [-h] -c KCONFIG_FILE -r RULES [-o OVERLAY_FILE]
options:
-h, --help show this help message and exit
-c, --config KCONFIG_FILE
.config file to be checked
-r, --rules RULES rules file to check against
-o, --overlay OVERLAY_FILE
file overlay over picked rules
$ ./tools/kconfig-checker/check.py check -r safety
usage: check.py check [-h] -c KCONFIG_FILE -r RULES [-o OVERLAY_FILE]
check.py check: error: argument -r/--rules: invalid choice: 'safety'
(choose from 'preempt_rt')
And that's by design, as an independent tool that can be later packaged.
Regarding the Makefile's own error handling, I'll touch upon that below.
> As far as I have seen when skimming through the kconfig policy checker
> code, it does not use any Kbuild variables. So, if it is being placed
> below tools/ and does not use Kbuild at all, and is expected to be run
> w/o Linux tree context at all: why do we need an additional top-level
> Makefile target for it at all (alongside of
> 'make tools/kconfig-policy-checker')?
The reason is the expected kernel configuration workflow, e.g.:
$ make defconfig # Generate a default .config
$ make debug.config # Add debug options to it
$ make menuconfig # Manually customize it
$ make RULES=preempt_rt checkconfig # Validate it
$ make menuconfig # Follow checkconfig advice
$ make RULES=preempt_rt checkconfig # Try again..
and so on.
So the "checkconfig" target fits that workflow, even when the checker
itself does not depend on any Kbuild internals.
The Makefile-side validation is also there to improve error handling for
that workflow:
$ make checkconfig
Usage: make RULES=<profile> [OVERLAY=<overlay>] checkconfig
Available RULES: preempt_rt
make[2]: *** [scripts/kconfig/Makefile:138: checkconfig] Error 2
Without it, the user just sees the lower-level script errors:
$ make checkconfig
usage: check.py check [-h] -c KCONFIG_FILE -r RULES [-o OVERLAY_FILE]
check.py check: error: argument -r/--rules: invalid choice: '' (choose from
'preempt_rt')
Both error messages are correct, but the former informs the user, exactly,
on how to call the Makefile target. This matches the aforementioned kernel
configuration workflow as well.
I hope this clarifies things a bit.
Thank you!
--
Ahmed S. Darwish
Linutronix GmbH