This is mostly for Sean, but no reason not to send it to the list.

About a year ago, I personally stopped using two spaces after periods in
writing. I was taught that way and always used that formatting in email
and on Usenet, but that style of formatting is fairly obsolete these days
and for various personal reasons I wanted to adopt the new formatting.

Policy currently largely, but not entirely, uses two spaces after periods.
When working on Policy, should I:

1. Use one space after a period in new text, let my editor reformat
   rewrapped paragraphs to use one space after a period, and not worry
   about the inconsistency. I think this is what's largely happening now.

2. Configure my editor to use two spaces after periods when editing Policy
   and try to consistently maintain that style.

3. (A bigger change.) Start adopting XKCD 1285 formatting for Policy in
   new text: each sentence on its own logical line (thus often longer than
   80 columns), with a newline at the end of each sentence.

Because the input is reStructuredText, I don't believe the whitespace
after periods makes a difference in the output. The only place I'm unsure
is with the PDF and texinfo output, since the spacing is preserved in the
input to TeX, but some spot checking seems to indicate that TeX makes its
own decisions and ignores the spacing.

At work, we use 3, and in general I prefer it, but it's a big change and
would mean lines in email messages for review would break the normal email
formatting conventions. It's quite nice in software forges and avoids the
problems with reflowing paragraphs causing spurious meaningless deltas in
Git, but as long as we're using email review, it might be a bridge too
far?

-- 
Russ Allbery ([email protected])              <https://www.eyrie.org/~eagle/>

Reply via email to