On 14/03/18 at 14:52 +0100, Mattia Rizzolo wrote: > On Wed, Mar 14, 2018 at 02:39:25PM +0100, Andreas Tille wrote: > > Is there any reason why the "Request membership" button is lacking for > > the qa team on Salsa? > > I don't remember whether I was the one who disabled it (but I don't > think so), but I approve the lack of that button. > > The reason is exactly in the message you quoted, we already received > join requests on salsa that don't match the goal of the team there. > > > Andreas (who intends to commit some patches for UDD) > > I added you as master of the udd project. > > There are these other people who are in the 'uddadm' LDAP group but not > in the udd project or qa team on salsa: > > * paulproteus > * laney > * ivodd > * richih > * tobald > > Except from ivodd I don't remember seeing any commits from any of them > in the last years, so I wonder if somebody should clean up ACLs a bit > here as well… (disclaimer: I didn't actually check, just going by > memory). > > > Whether adding people to the single UDD project is enough/fine instead > of adding people like you to the qa team is up to discuss, but > apparently nobody is up to discuss it in thise thread, and nobody but > buxy took his time to answer reply to my mail challenging my opinion.
As a data point, I also added Andreas to the qa group (as Developer) after he asked in private mail and I didn't check debian-qa@ ;) I have no opinion on whether we should add people to projects or to the qa group. I've added 'clean up the addadm LDAP group' to my to-do list (low priority) Lucas
