Package: release.debian.org Severity: wishlist User: [email protected] Usertags: britney
Hi, I'd like to open a discussion about using https://debaudit.debian.net data to gate testing migrations. The service is quite new, so this would likely need a long testing period, but I guess that it's probably better to open the discussion early. In short, debaudit currently includes two "checkers" (orig-check and git2dsc). orig-check ensures that the orig tarball in Debian matches upstream's. git2dsc ensures that the Vcs-Git repository matches the Debian source package. I think that it would make sense to block migration when packages regress (similar to what was implemented for reproducible builds, if I remember correctly) -- that would allow packages that fail in testing to still migrate, while still gradually improving the overall status. The current regressions can be browsed on: https://debaudit.debian.net/orig-check/regressions/forky and https://debaudit.debian.net/git2dsc/regressions/forky There are currently 14 source packages that would be blocked because of orig-check regressions, and 32 because of git2dsc regressions. I'm not aware of false positives (= AFAIK, regressions are real problems that should be fixed). Data is refreshed every hour, and there's a JSON export with the relevant data: https://debaudit.debian.net/results.json Example: "aspell-ml": { "versions": [ /* ... details about each known version ... */ ], "migration_status": { "orig-check": { "can_migrate": false, "sid": { "diagnostic": "220 - uscan failed -- network error", "version": "0.04-1-11", "dsc_sha256": "4d1a4a2890eeb834dcdae96e5b80d8c3059cef021db5eb03d894bee8bed8e0e8", "url": "/orig-check/result/4d1a4a2890eeb834dcdae96e5b80d8c3059cef021db5eb03d894bee8bed8e0e8" }, "testing": { "diagnostic": "800 - identical after tarball normalization", "version": "0.04-1-10", "dsc_sha256": "2662500adb5b4e355e545b42e271dec5ae7b18d28db99b2df8883a15ea33232e", "url": "/orig-check/result/2662500adb5b4e355e545b42e271dec5ae7b18d28db99b2df8883a15ea33232e" } }, "git2dsc": { "can_migrate": false, "sid": { "diagnostic": "700 - generated dsc differs", "version": "0.04-1-11", "dsc_sha256": "4d1a4a2890eeb834dcdae96e5b80d8c3059cef021db5eb03d894bee8bed8e0e8", "url": "/git2dsc/result/4d1a4a2890eeb834dcdae96e5b80d8c3059cef021db5eb03d894bee8bed8e0e8" }, "testing": { "diagnostic": "910 - git-generated dsc identical to archive dsc after normalization", "version": "0.04-1-10", "dsc_sha256": "2662500adb5b4e355e545b42e271dec5ae7b18d28db99b2df8883a15ea33232e", "url": "/git2dsc/result/2662500adb5b4e355e545b42e271dec5ae7b18d28db99b2df8883a15ea33232e" } } } }, Best, Lucas
