Dear Raul, you wrote (25 May 2003): > On the other hand, if you could show that the May 15 mechanism > violates monotonicity, then I'd be opposed to it.
Situation 1: 40 ACB 32 BAC 28 CBA A:B=40:60 A:C=72:28 B:C=32:68 Default option: A. Quorum: 30. B meets quorum. C fails to meet quorum. Manoj's May 15 proposal would choose B. Situation 2: 3 ACB voters change their minds to CAB. 37 ACB 32 BAC 28 CBA 03 CAB A:B=40:60 A:C=69:31 B:C=32:68 Default option: A. Quorum: 30. B meets quorum. C meets quorum. Manoj's May 15 proposal would choose A. Markus Schulze
