I am for adding this datatype back. While it may not be part of the SQL
Standard, it is a common datatype supported by multiple vendors. Having
this datatype supported helps with the migration of applications and at
the end of the day making it easier for applications to migrate is more
important than basing a decision soley on whether the datatype is
supported by the SQL standards.
+1 (unofficial vote) for this addition
Rick Hillegas (JIRA) wrote:
Re-enable the TINYINT datatype
------------------------------
Key: DERBY-695
URL: http://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/DERBY-695
Project: Derby
Type: New Feature
Reporter: Rick Hillegas
I would like to collect here the arguments for and against re-enabling the
TINYINT datatype. Once this discussion calms down, we can schedule a vote on
the issue.
Background: Cloudscape used to support the TINYINT datatype, which was an 8 bit int. This
datatype was hidden from customers as part of an effort to remove all datatypes not
supported by DB2. Re-enabling the datatype would not require a lot of effort. Some
arguments for and against re-enabling this datatype can be found on the November 2005
email thread titled "New features for next release .... (Was: Grant and Revoke ...
DERBY-464...)".
Here are the arguments in favor so far:
+ This datatype is defined by one of our key standards, JDBC. It is in JDBC 2,
3, and 4, all of the JDBC revs supported by Derby 10.2.
+ This datatype is supported by some important databases, including MySQL,
Microsoft SQL Server, and Sybase.
Here are the arguments against so far:
- This datatype is not defined by our other key standard, ANSI SQL. Here our
two main standards diverge.
- This datatype is not supported by some important databases, including Oracle,
DB2, and (some) Informix databases.
Against this proposal, it was also argued that there was some sort of friction
with ODBC. I do not understand this argument: SQL_TINYINT is an ODBC datatype.
See
http://msdn.microsoft.com/library/default.asp?url=/library/en-us/odbc/htm/odbcsql_data_types.asp.
A friction with .NET was also suggested but I don't understand this either. "byte" and
"Sbyte" are the .NET 8-bit integer types. See
http://www.codersource.net/csharp_tutorial_data_types.html.
A friction with Perl was also suggested but I don't understand this either.
