Kristian Waagan wrote:
Myrna van Lunteren wrote:
Hi,

I've been struggling with the semantics/use/purpose of the flags, in
particular 'Existing Application Impact' and 'Release Note Needed'...

I'm a bit lost on these two too!

On a Jira issue I worked on, requiring a release note, I first didn't tick any of them because it was not clear that it needed a release note.

When this was determined, I ticked the "Release Note Needed" and when the release note was done, I was adviced to untick the "Release Note Needed" and tick "Existing Application Impact".

I did as described above, but noticed that the "Release Note Needed" was later ticked again by someone else, possibly because the release note generator did not pick it up or something.

Does anyone have an answer for me on this one?
Based on the descriptions below, I believe the process described is incorrect and that "Release Note Needed" should stay ticked.



thanks,
Hi Kristian,

You are correct. The ReleaseNotesGenerator looks for the "Release Note Needed" flag in order to compile its list of JIRAs which have release notes. I suppose that the ReleaseNotesGenerator could just look for issues which have a releaseNote.html attached.

The current approach makes it easy to change your mind and decide that a JIRA doesn't need a release note: you just uncheck a box. Changing your mind would be harder under the other approach: you would have to delete all of the versions of the attached release note--the power to do this seems to be limited to JIRA administrators.

Regards,
-Rick

Reply via email to