The tests ran cleanly for me under 1.4 also.
Regards,
-Rick
Rick Hillegas wrote:
Hi Narayanan,
Not a stupid question at all. No, I ran with 1.5. I'll try 1.4 next.
Thanks for the advice!
Cheers,
-Rick
Narayanan wrote:
Sorry if this is a stupid question, but you ran the tests with 1.4?
Narayanan
Rick Hillegas wrote:
The regression tests ran cleanly for me after removing this jar file
and rebuilding Derby.
Regards,
-Rick
Rick Hillegas wrote:
Hi Knut,
I think that xml-apis.jar was added in revision 395643. Here's the
svn info entry for that submission:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
r395643 | fuzzylogic | 2006-04-20 10:07:39 -0700 (Thu, 20 Apr 2006)
| 4 lines
DERBY-1078: Move more files to 1.3 source/target tags. Add xml-api
jars to
compile XML classes with 1.3. Break shared hierarchy up into 1.3
and 1.4 parts.
JDK 1.3 now passes basic tests when compiled with 1.5.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
I have repeated your experiment of successfully building Derby
without xml-apis.jar. Narayanan raises a cautionary note about
running the xml tests so I'm running all the regression tests now.
I'll let you know how it turns out.
Thanks,
-Rick
Knut Anders Hatlen wrote:
Narayanan wrote:
Knut Anders Hatlen wrote:
Hi,
I took a brief look at the contents of tools/java/xml-apis.jar
in the subversion repository, and it looked as if most of the
classes are part of the Java 1.4.2 runtime library. I also tried
to remove the file and all references to it in the build system,
and the code still built just fine. Does anyone know if the file
is still needed? Or was it only needed before when we built the
code against the Java 1.3 runtime library?
Thanks,
I believe xalan 2.7 jars are needed to run xml tests. The jars
that come with 1.4 are 2.4.1 and are not sufficient.
Thanks Narayanan,
I'm aware of the fact that we need a newer Xalan for some of the
XML support at runtime. What I would like to know, is if
xml-apis.jar is still needed in order to build Derby. I think it
mostly contains interfaces, not Xalan implementation classes, and
these interfaces now seem to be part of Java SE. If it's not
needed to build Derby anymore, I think it would be good to remove
it from the repository. The fewer third-party jar files we have
checked in, the better, IMO.
