Hi Máirín,
Thanks for the link to the user base, that's actually new to me (or I've
forgotten about it) - a good resource.
I don't see any specific info that would help answer some of the
questions we've uncovered in this discussion. It would be great if we
could reach out to Fedora users to answer questions such as:
1 - How many operating systems do you typically have installed on your
main machine?
2 - How often do you use the ability to boot your machine into older
kernels? Other OSs?
3 - What causes you to boot into old kernels?
4 - How often do you select something other than the default in the boot
menu (i.e. grub2)
The questions might need some polishing, but those are the ones I can
pick off the top of my head. A quick survey might get some valuable
data here.
I'm not sure if there is an actual project waiting for our input here or
if we're just discussing things, so maybe we have some time to collect
some data?
I like the idea of relating the old kernels with the rescue concept. I
suspect you're right that most users don't use old kernels (is there an
auto-prune for this, like keep the last 3 kernels only?). They probably
only access those when something goes wrong with the latest kernel, like
in a rescue situation. I've had to access old kernels myself and I'm
certainly no developer, so the use case exists (I can't be the only one!?)
I guess the core of my concern is that we are cleaning up clutter for
users who don't mind the clutter, or actually want the clutter. I want
to avoid designing for ourselves by focusing on our actual user's needs
and tasks. Maybe I just lacked the knowledge about the user research
that has gone on prior to this discussion.
What are your thoughts on the need to collect some data from Fedora
users via a survey? Useful or redundant?
Thanks,
Kirk
On 06/20/2012 07:30 PM, Máirín Duffy wrote:
Hi Kirk,
On 2012-06-20 19:04, Kirk Bridger wrote:
1 - I think data should be collected before we make assumptions about
our user base.
We need to take the user base as defined by the project board as a given:
https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/User_base
It wasn't determined lightly and it was researched and deliberated and
discussed throughout the community pretty carefully.
2 - I think categorizing is a better solution than hiding, as users
with lots of kernels/OSs are more likely to be switching more often,
vs users with just a few. The value of reducing clutter is minimized
is clutter consists of 3-5 items, and hiding things makes it harder to
do what you want to do.
Don't forget to consider, along with majority of users vs minority of
users, how frequently vs infrequently users will be:
- Switching OSes
- Switching kernels
I believe switching OSes is going to be more frequent for even the
Pokemon 'gotta catch 'em all' distro enthusiast than switching kernels
within each OS, and the mockup that Martin put together definitely
optimizes for switching OSes instead of switching kernels. The only
user I know of that realistically switches between specific kernels on
any kind of frequent basis is a kernel developer, and I haven't seen
any complaints or concerns from kernel developers about the change.
That being said, I can certainly reach out to a few and get some
feedback from them, but I think they probably - since their menu has
so many entries anyway - have highly customized grub conf files anyway
so any defaults are likely not to affect them.
3 - I think removing clutter is a good goal, provided it meets our
users needs (see comment #1)
+99 I'm glad we seem to be all on the same page about this part, we
just need to sort out more of the other details.
~m
_______________________________________________
design-team mailing list
design-team@lists.fedoraproject.org
https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/design-team
_______________________________________________
design-team mailing list
design-team@lists.fedoraproject.org
https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/design-team
