Mimi Yin wrote:
+ For first-time Received Items, the Item is In if you are in the To: CC: or BCC: fields, even if you sent it.
What if you received the item from a mailing list? You (your email address corresponding to the "me" identity) is nowhere to be found in any of these fields. Should the item not be In then?

There's a third category missing in your discussion. Seems like emails can end up being neither in nor out. If it's not the case (and we have only in and out), then the logic is more simple: the "out" determination is fairly simple (you are in the From field). For the rest, if it's not out, then it's in.

I also don't see the semantic difference between "first time" and "update" that justify having 2 different logics. After all, the "update" could be a complete rewrite and look like a "first time". If you and me were to share a collection, why would an email (not sent to me) be "out" but the same message (with the same recipient data) be "in" if it was an update of an existing one? I fail to see the reason of having this extra logic.

Cheers,
- Philippe

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Open Source Applications Foundation "Design" mailing list
http://lists.osafoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/design

Reply via email to