I'd just like to throw my thoughts in to the ring for this, but the genunix 
page lists "Binary only packages allowed" as a goal..

That is, in my opinion, a /TERRIBLE/ idea, and likely to get people in more 
trouble and reflect worse on (open)solaris than just simply not having the 
packages at all. Any sort of poor software, either through malice (trojans) or 
incompetence (running being heavily dependent on the builder's specific system 
setup) can be sneaked in with absolutely no oversight. 

I think an SFE-like "build recipe" and an automated build system is much more 
likely to attract quality software than untrusted binary blobs being put on 
what will be seen as an offical repository (no amount of small text will 
detract from the fact that it is pkg.opensolaris.org/foo, and therefore 
perceived as "official" ). 

Binary blobs are fine, but they ought to be the exception, and ought to require 
human intervention that they are trusted enough to deliver binary ( I'm sure if 
adobe came up and wanted to dump stuff in contrib/ that they'd be greenlit. )
-- 
This message posted from opensolaris.org

Reply via email to