When you are telling that you select French, or English, and so, all dialects should be installed for them, why do we have that separation in different packages though? Shouldn't we only have one "English", "French", … package?
I don't understand the difference between: $ locale -a | grep ^fr fr_BE.utf8 fr_CA.utf8 fr_CH.utf8 fr_FR.utf8 fr_LU.utf8 and the script outputting only fr/fr_FR/fr_CA. There is no translation available in /usr/share/locale for fr_BE for instance? How this does differ fr_BE, from fr_FR, as it's the same currency, time format and no specific string (as no separate langpack) and so on? It seems that a little bit later in the comment, you reach to the same conclusion. I really think that if we decide to always ship all variants (as the script requires right now), it should be one single package: easier maintenance, list and logic. On 1.: on the contrary, if we go to install all dialects selecting a given language, I would rather packs them all in a single (well, single as "per type", keeping dict, libreoffice and such separated) package. As we require them to be installed on the system anyway, this doesn't make any difference for the user, but ease our side. 1.5: we can debug that later on, but it seems we want to have "fr" anyway as we have "en", correct? Or we want people to specifically select, like fr_BE (to have the specifics for this locale), but still install all langpaks without having "fr" listed. So my question in that case would be: what is "en", then? People would rather select a specific one, like en_US to have $ as currency and a weird date format, rather than en_GB, which would use £ and anotter date format :) 2. -> agreed, we can work towards that. I don't understand though why we would have "en" and "en_US", but not "fr", and "fr_FR" as told in my previous paragraph. 3. Hum, I still don't understand the "if we decide to split the english langpacks", they are already splitted. The original issue which triggered that discussion is that on a fresh install, check-language-support complains about missing: "hunspell-en-au hunspell-en-ca hunspell-en-gb hunspell-en-za hyphen-en-ca hyphen-en-gb libreoffice-help-en-gb libreoffice-l10n-en-gb libreoffice-l10n-en-za mythes-en-au thunderbird-locale-en-gb" (I'm not only talking about the main langpacks, but for everything we split in langpacks: dictionaries, libreoffice, main applications…) -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Desktop Packages, which is subscribed to language-selector in Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1797860 Title: Language selection installs too many packages Status in language-selector package in Ubuntu: New Bug description: Multiple issues arise when installing any languages in ubuntu: 1. if you select en_GB, en_US is selected instead 2. if you select fr_FR, fr_FR + en_US is selected 3. As soon as en_US is selected (which is always right now), en is then selected, which in turns requests installing all en_* languages. 4. ubiquity, if en_US is selected, only install en_US + en packages, but then, check-language-support wants to bring back all en_* variants (hunspell-en-au hunspell-en-ca hunspell-en-gb hunspell-en-za hyphen-en-ca hyphen-en-gb libreoffice-help-en-gb libreoffice-l10n-en-gb libreoffice-l10n-en-za mythes-en-au thunderbird-locale-en-gb in cosmic for instance) which were discared by ubiquity. The last point is due to /usr/share/language-tools/language-options reporting needing (in the fr_FR default installation for instance): en_US fr_FR en en_AU fr en_GB en_CA A big rework/revamp would be needed in language support, account-services and ubiquity, backed up with tests. Ideally, the seed and check-language-support will always be in sync, the list of package to install is strictly regulated by check-language-support (which is supposed to be the case below, but we see in 4. that it's not), and we limit the number of components disagreeing in which languages are installed/supported. We need to take into account ofc the debian singularirity about generated locales. To manage notifications about this bug go to: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/language-selector/+bug/1797860/+subscriptions -- Mailing list: https://launchpad.net/~desktop-packages Post to : [email protected] Unsubscribe : https://launchpad.net/~desktop-packages More help : https://help.launchpad.net/ListHelp
