Hi Excalibur list (this is my fist post),

 1. A series of short tutorials: We could create a couple short
 tutorials/introductions somewhat like Picocontainer's "One minute
 description,Two minute tutorial,Five minute introduction" set. These
 could be placed in the wiki.

This is a must. Either in the way pico have it, or in some use cases for which Excalibur could be used. The examples in the repository are far from beeing useful, because they are too simple and just show a startup. A better Swing/SWT example, a simple "this-is-my-server-for-some-service" example and something like this would be very useful.

 2. Maven plugins like Turbine's META [1]: What about creating a maven
 plugin that could setup a Fortress or ECM development environment in
 one command.

I think this isn't that good. It may help to setup a project for an experienced Excalibur developer, but the entry barrier isn't lowered with that.

 3. A simple binary distribution: Unzipping the distribution would
 give you all the libraries, example configuration files and the Java
 Service Wrapper already setup. Maybe you could have a couple
 versions: a lightweight distro which only has a trivial example
 included versus a "Kitchen Sink" distro that shows how you can tie
 several components together.

That is a good one I think. With a binary distro a new developer would not have to bother with the dependencies, wich is quite nerving.

 4. Eclipse Plugins: I'm doing some plugin development now and maybe
 later this year I can write some custom editors for role and
 configuration files or for generating meta-data or maybe even a
 graphical editor for wiring up the container (drag and drop the
 component roles). I'm not sure what type of plugin would be useful,
 so I'd appreciate some ideas.

That sounds interesting also, but again IMHO it is for more experienced developers.
Excalibur is a big tool and if you give 'newbies' tools wich generate the neccessary code in a certain way they could use it but don't get the concept of it and will never learn it like when they write it by hand.


Also 5. Documentation:
I think some more and more and much more documentation in each direction would greatly help developing with Excalibur.
Currently most things I have to figure out by searching/looking through the sources.
Some documentation of the concept of containers, components and roles would help clear new developers minds.
Also some documentation of the big picture behind Excalibur would greatly help I think.


Regards
Markus
--
>
> emedia-solutions wolf
> Wedeler Landstrasse 63
> 22559 Hamburg
> (040) 550 083 70
>
>>  web: http://www.emedia-solutions-wolf.de
>> mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>>  pgp: http://wwwkeys.de.pgp.net
>

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Reply via email to