Not a "vote" in any way, but experience has shown (in
various other projects) that those "last minute"
additions almost invariably cause problems :)
On May 23, 2006, at 1:43 AM, Aaron Mulder wrote:
I don't agree. 1.1 is not yet out the door, and if anything, it looks
like 1.2 will take longer than anticipated. Minor changes, necessary,
I vote 1.1. Remember, this change takes pressure off since we'll be
able to release more features as plugins. I'm strongly in favor of
taking things out of the critical path, whereas deferring to 1.2 will
extend the critical path by another 3+ months.
Thanks,
Aaron
On 5/22/06, Matt Hogstrom <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
I agree that they are necessary. Let's put them in 1.2. 1.1 is
almost out the door and adding new
features at this point is very late in the game. We're currently
30 days past our original date and
almost 5 months past the 1.0 release.
Please defer these till 1.2.
Matt
Aaron Mulder wrote:
> We can call them what we want, but I think all the features are
> necessary, in particular in order to support plugins. The
advantage
> of adding the first two features is that they let us take a lot of
> other features *out* of the critical path, and release them as
plugins
> (also letting us support non-ASL licensed providers).
Basically, the
> idea is to replace a properties file with a GBean, since you can't
> effectively add to a properties file at plugin installation
time, but
> you can certainly add GBeans. Bottom line, it's a small impact
change
> (console only, change the lookup logic that's already
encapsulated in
> a helper class to do a GBean interface query instead of a
properties
> file load), and it has significant benefits (new JMS providers or
> security providers can be added at runtime via plugins and do
not need
> to be hardcoded into the Geronimo distribution).
>
> Thanks,
> Aaron
>
> On 5/22/06, Matt Hogstrom <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>> Based on the list below I think 1,2 and 3 are new function and
4 is a
>> bug fix.
>>
>> Aaron Mulder wrote:
>> > Here are the things that I still want to squeeze into 1.1:
>> > - fix console JMS to accept new providers at runtime
>> > - fix console security realms to accept new providers at runtime
>> > - add a missing Geronimo security provider to console
security realms
>> > - fix hot deploy dir so it notices files updated while the
server was
>> > down and deletes files if they are undeployed some other way
>> >
>> > There are also AFAIK a number of not-yet-applied patches to
review.
>>
>> Yes, there are several.
>>
>> I'm testing some performance related code. I'm waiting and hoping
>> Codehaus comes up soon :)
>>
>> >
>> > Thanks,
>> > Aaron
>> >
>> >
>> >
>>
>
>
>
