Re: Gshell fails to launch on trunk

[Donald Woods]

Hmmm. Sounds like our build needs to either create this conf file based on our dependency levels or change how GShell is setup....

-Donald

Jason Warner wrote:

Sorry for the confusion, David.  Responses inline.

On Tue, Mar 11, 2008 at 6:54 PM, David Jencks <[EMAIL PROTECTED] <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>> wrote:

    On Mar 11, 2008, at 12:37 PM, Jason Warner wrote:

     > I checked out the latest trunk and tried to launch gshell, but
     > found that it failed due to an error in plexus.  The problem seems
     > to be caused by the recent update to using mina 1.1.5.

    update of what?





     > The 1.0-alpha-1 version of gshell that is being used is telling
     > plexus to look for version 1.1.2 of mina-core.  When it doesn't
     > find it, it blows up and the console isn't launched.  This can be
     > fixed by changing the version of mina that it is searching for in
     > the gsh-classworlds.conf file in the etc directory.

    Doesn't that mean the the geronimo configuration for gshell is
    specifying mina-core 1.1.2?  How is gshell specifying something else
    as you say above?




     > What would be the proper fix for this?  1.0-alpha-1 is the latest
     > tag.  It looks like trunk was recently updated to use mina-1.1.6.

    trunk of what?


GShell trunk has recently been updated to mina-1.1.6


     >   I imagine we'd have the same problem using a snapshot build of
     > trunk given that there's a version difference.  Is there another
     > way to fix this problem or do we need to move gshell trunk over to
     > 1.1.5 and then include the snapshot build in geronimo trunk?

    I don't understand where the problem actually is.  I would start by
    making sure that the version of mina-core that is installed for
    gshell to use is the one specified in etc/sdh-classworlds.conf and
    preferably the same one as in the geronimo repository, if there is
    one.  As long as these are the same I'd expect plexus to be happy.
    Then we can try to figure out what the latest version of mina gshell
    1.0-alpha-1 can work with.

    Maybe I'm missing the problem entirely...
    thanks
    david jencks





     >
     > Thanks,
     >
     >
     > --
     > ~Jason Warner




--
~Jason Warner

Geronimo trunk has moved from a dependency on mina 1.1.2 to a dependency on mina 1.1.5. I'm not quite sure what you're asking with this but I'll try to answer anyways. The version of gshell that is used in trunk currently is 1.0-alpha-1. The gsh-classworlds.conf file for this version of gshell is looking for mina 1.1.2. Geronimo no longer has a dependency on mina 1.1.2. It is now dependent on mina 1.1.5. Because of this, Plexus (which attempts to load the classes specified in gsh-classworlds.conf) crashes on load. Halfway through my responses, I just realized that I'm probably blowing the problem way out of proportion. I misunderstood how gshell was assembled in the server, but I think I understand it now. At least, I understand it well enough to point out that this can actually be fixed easily by updating the gsh-classworlds.conf file in assemblies/geronimo-boilerplate-minimal/src/main/underlay/etc/ to use mina-1.1.5. I can see now why you were so confused, David. Sorry about that.

smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME Cryptographic Signature