On 9/26/26 13:37, Jason Harmening wrote:
I'd definitely agree on getting rid of the min/max/pref distinction and
just having a single version.
It's always seemed like a stretch to imagine any dependent module making a
meaningful distinction between those 3 versions in a way that wouldn't be
extremely fragile.
Ideally, some form of module-specific versioning still seems useful for
addressing scenarios like the mixer_init() case I described above. Bumping
the global version for cases like that seems very heavy-handed, though
maybe it wouldn't be such a big issue in practice, or maybe some of the
recent suggestions for consolidating those version bumps could be useful in
cases like this.
We already use __FreeBSD_version to mean there is a KPI or KBI change. I also
think the recent thread on bumps was a bit exaggerated.
Here's some data vs anecdotal "we bump too much" feelings:
git log --first-parent -G __FreeBSD_version --format=%cs sys/sys/param.h | uniq
-c | head -30
1 2026-09-14
1 2026-09-09
1 2026-09-06
1 2026-09-05
1 2026-09-02
1 2026-08-27
1 2026-08-12
1 2026-06-19
1 2026-04-30
1 2026-04-25
1 2026-04-23
1 2026-04-06
1 2026-03-21
1 2026-03-12
1 2026-02-13
1 2026-01-25
1 2026-01-23
1 2026-01-16
1 2026-01-13
1 2025-12-18
1 2025-12-15
1 2025-12-09
1 2025-11-02
1 2025-10-30
1 2025-10-21
1 2025-09-29
1 2025-09-04
1 2025-08-18
1 2025-08-17
1 2025-08-16
As you can see, we've yet to have multiple bumps on a single day in the past
year (which I
agree should be avoided), but bumps are also rather sporadic. We have a few
weeks a year
where they cluster (multiple bumps in a week), but we also have entire months
without a
single bump.
--
John Baldwin