Hi,

not sure if this is best place to start a discussion, but I wanted to throw out my view on a minimum viable calling solution for loop.

The link clicker in my view is not an acceptable solution for the end user.
It would be as if I give my parents a phone number where reachable for the next X hours, but if they want to call me tomorrow they first need to ask me via email (or some other communication tool) what my number today is. In my experience this is really hard to explain to non-technical people. The other reason is that on mobile devices it is not easy to copy a URL from a calling app into some other communication tool to send it out to some.

On the other hand on desktop I don't see why we have to have an address book integration a.k.a. contacts. This is only valuable if my address book contains the Firefox Account email of my contact, or the contact has verified his phone number via the Loop MSISDN server. Both are pretty unlikely in my opinion.

Never the less I think a direct calling solution based on authenticated URLs is viable. If we integrate Firefox Accounts that would allow me to hand out either my email address or maybe permanent URL like loop.com/nils as the URL where I'm permanently reachable. Without an address book integrated into the Loop client this would require some form of input field where I can enter the email address or URL of the target user. But that should be easy to implement. We could also store once dialed email addresses or URLs locally for convenience until we have a server based address book integration.

Best regards
  Nils Ohlmeier
_______________________________________________
dev-media mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-media

Reply via email to