Gervase Markham wrote:
> Regarding https://blog.startcom.org/?p=86
> 
> Assuming Eddy's screenshots are accurate (and they seem to be to me), it 
> is true that there is now very little difference between HTTP and non-EV 
> HTTPS. Is that by design? (Are we trying to move all significant sites 
> to EV?)

Eddy's screenshots are taken on linux, which is absolutely the least 
noticeable of the three platforms in terms of state transition.  The 
discussion around remedying that specific situation is happening (well, 
trying to happen!) in bug 430790.

More broadly yes, there is less distinction between http and DV-SSL than 
there is between DV-SSL and EV-SSL.  I would urge people interested in 
*that* debate go read bug 414627, where careful arguments were made by 
numerous people in support of various solutions that I think it will do 
no good to re-visit here.

> To me, in the non-EV case, it isn't obvious where the padlock has gone
> and what a user should do instead to check where they are. Do we plan to 
> educate users about the new emphasis on identity and the new UI? If so, how?

Talking about the change in UI is absolutely something we should do, and 
Alex started a thread on precisely that subject in d.a.f a while ago, here:

http://groups.google.com/group/mozilla.dev.apps.firefox/browse_thread/thread/6de183b9057aa142#

Which I replied to with some information about the ways we're trying to 
bring out the message here:

http://groups.google.com/group/mozilla.dev.apps.firefox/msg/53570f2c3d3a8516

> Lastly, the tooltip on the identity button for non-EV just says
> (in the case of the site above, as an example) "Verified by Startcom 
> Ltd" - surely, to match the relative importance of the bits of 
> information in the identity dialog, it should say "startcom.org - 
> operator identity unknown" or somesuch?

To be honest, my gut reaction is that it doesn't feel necessary - 
clicking will get you that information quicker than a hover, and the 
tooltip is right now a consistent message about verifier, as 
counterpoint to the button's contents (for EV) and popup (for all types) 
being principally focused on owner.  But I don't have a really strong 
opinion on it, so if people are interested in this discussion, I suggest 
we file a bug and chase down options.

Cheers,

Johnathan


_______________________________________________
dev-security mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-security

Reply via email to