[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/AMQ-3543?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=13127876#comment-13127876
]
Christopher Barrow edited comment on AMQ-3543 at 10/14/11 9:35 PM:
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Wow, thanks for such a quick response! Just want to check my understanding of
your fix. Does it mean the received MESSAGE with reply-to ( received as a
result of the SEND) will now have reply-to = '/temp-queue/...' or
'/temp-topic/...'?
What about the case where two connections are used (one connection owns the
temporary destination and emits the SEND with reply-to, a second connection
receives the MESSAGE). Presumably in that case the reply-to would have to be
'/remote-temp-queue/...' or '/remote-temp-topic/...' since the temporary
destination actually belongs to the other connection?
was (Author: chris.barrow):
Wow, thanks for such a quick response! Just want to check my understanding
of your fix. Does it mean the received MESSAGE with reply-to ( received as a
result of the SEND) will now have reply-to = '/temp-queue/...' or
'/temp-topic/...'?
What about the case where two connections are used (one connection owns the
temporary destination and emits the SEND with reply-to, a second connection
receives the MESSAGE). Presumably in that case the reply-to would have to be
'/remote-temp-queue/...' or '/remote-temp-topic/...' since the queue actually
belongs to the other connection?
> STOMP connector: unexpected reply-to value for remote temporary topic
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: AMQ-3543
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/AMQ-3543
> Project: ActiveMQ
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: stomp
> Affects Versions: 5.x
> Reporter: Christopher Barrow
> Assignee: Timothy Bish
> Priority: Minor
> Fix For: 5.6.0
>
> Attachments: StompRemoteTempTopic.java
>
>
> The reply-to header on a MESSAGE frame resulting from the sending of a
> message (SEND) with the reply-to header set to a temporary topic is in the
> form /temp-topic/<local-temp-topic-name> rather than the expected
> /remote-temp-topic/<system_generated_name>
> This only happens when the same connection is used for sending and receiving
> messages. When a temporary queue is used, the reply-to appears as
> /remote-temp-queue/xxx as expected. So even if one takes the position that it
> is reasonable for the local name to be used given that everything is on the
> same connection, there is an inconsistency between the topic and queue cases.
> For our purposes we would prefer that the remote form be used always, because
> we are actually servicing two different users on the same connection (first
> user does the SEND, second user receives the MESSAGE).
> Test case for the underlying ActiveMQ bug is attached:
> StompRemoteTempTopic.java
> To reproduce, drop this file into $ACTIVEMQ_HOME/example/src, edit build.xml
> in the example
> directory to add the following:
> <target name="bug" depends="compile" description="Runs test case for replyTo
> TempTopic bug">
> <echo>Running a Stomp example</echo>
> <java classname="StompRemoteTempTopic" fork="yes" maxmemory="100M">
> <classpath refid="javac.classpath" />
> <jvmarg value="-server" />
> </java>
> </target>
> and run by issuing the command "ant bug". Output is as follows:
> [echo] Running a Stomp example
> [java] =====================================================
> [java] Test run using temporary topic
> [java] -----------------------------------------------------
> [java] Sending request message: SEND with
> reply-to=/temp-topic/2C26441740C0ECC9tt1
> [java] Received request message: MESSAGE with
> reply-to=/temp-topic/2C26441740C0ECC9tt1
> [java] Response MESSAGE received
> [java] =====================================================
> [java] Test run using temporary queue
> [java] -----------------------------------------------------
> [java] Sending request message: SEND with
> reply-to=/temp-queue/2C26441740C0ECC9tt1
> [java] Received request message: MESSAGE with
> reply-to=/remote-temp-queue/ID:ChrisBarrow-lap-61815-1318539910206-4:6:1
> [java] Response MESSAGE received
> This makes it easy to see that for the queue case the reply-to is set to the
> remote temporary queue but for the topic case the local temporary topic is
> specified.
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
If you think it was sent incorrectly, please contact your JIRA administrators:
https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/ContactAdministrators!default.jspa
For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira
