[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/AMQ-3635?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel ]
Timothy Bish updated AMQ-3635: ------------------------------ Description: On the JMS bridge topic connector, if I set the outboundClientId but not the localClientId, then the outbound client id will not be set. This is because the JmsTopicConnector only sets the outboundClientId if the localClientId is set. This appears to be a bug. Here is 5.4.2 JmsTopicConnector.initializeForeignTopicConnection {code} protected void initializeForeignTopicConnection() throws NamingException, JMSException { if (outboundTopicConnection == null) { // get the connection factories if (outboundTopicConnectionFactory == null) { // look it up from JNDI if (outboundTopicConnectionFactoryName != null) { outboundTopicConnectionFactory = (TopicConnectionFactory)jndiOutboundTemplate .lookup(outboundTopicConnectionFactoryName, TopicConnectionFactory.class); if (outboundUsername != null) { outboundTopicConnection = outboundTopicConnectionFactory .createTopicConnection(outboundUsername, outboundPassword); } else { outboundTopicConnection = outboundTopicConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(); } } else { throw new JMSException("Cannot create localConnection - no information"); } } else { if (outboundUsername != null) { outboundTopicConnection = outboundTopicConnectionFactory .createTopicConnection(outboundUsername, outboundPassword); } else { outboundTopicConnection = outboundTopicConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(); } } } >>>> if (localClientId != null && localClientId.length() > 0) { // >>>> CHECKS for existence of localClientId outboundTopicConnection.setClientID(getOutboundClientId()); // THEN uses outboundClientId } outboundTopicConnection.start(); } {code} I'm thinking the above code should check for existence of outboundClientId instead of localClientId Compare this to: {code} protected void initializeLocalTopicConnection() throws NamingException, JMSException { if (localTopicConnection == null) { // get the connection factories if (localTopicConnectionFactory == null) { if (embeddedConnectionFactory == null) { // look it up from JNDI if (localConnectionFactoryName != null) { localTopicConnectionFactory = (TopicConnectionFactory)jndiLocalTemplate .lookup(localConnectionFactoryName, TopicConnectionFactory.class); if (localUsername != null) { localTopicConnection = localTopicConnectionFactory .createTopicConnection(localUsername, localPassword); } else { localTopicConnection = localTopicConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(); } } else { throw new JMSException("Cannot create localConnection - no information"); } } else { localTopicConnection = embeddedConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(); } } else { if (localUsername != null) { localTopicConnection = localTopicConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(localUsername, localPassword); } else { localTopicConnection = localTopicConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(); } } } >>>> if (localClientId != null && localClientId.length() > 0) { // >>>> CHECKS for existence of localClientId localTopicConnection.setClientID(getLocalClientId()); // THEN uses localClientId } localTopicConnection.start(); } {code} was: On the JMS bridge topic connector, if I set the outboundClientId but not the localClientId, then the outbound client id will not be set. This is because the JmsTopicConnector only sets the outboundClientId if the localClientId is set. This appears to be a bug. Here is 5.4.2 JmsTopicConnector.initializeForeignTopicConnection protected void initializeForeignTopicConnection() throws NamingException, JMSException { if (outboundTopicConnection == null) { // get the connection factories if (outboundTopicConnectionFactory == null) { // look it up from JNDI if (outboundTopicConnectionFactoryName != null) { outboundTopicConnectionFactory = (TopicConnectionFactory)jndiOutboundTemplate .lookup(outboundTopicConnectionFactoryName, TopicConnectionFactory.class); if (outboundUsername != null) { outboundTopicConnection = outboundTopicConnectionFactory .createTopicConnection(outboundUsername, outboundPassword); } else { outboundTopicConnection = outboundTopicConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(); } } else { throw new JMSException("Cannot create localConnection - no information"); } } else { if (outboundUsername != null) { outboundTopicConnection = outboundTopicConnectionFactory .createTopicConnection(outboundUsername, outboundPassword); } else { outboundTopicConnection = outboundTopicConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(); } } } >>>> if (localClientId != null && localClientId.length() > 0) { // >>>> CHECKS for existence of localClientId outboundTopicConnection.setClientID(getOutboundClientId()); // THEN uses outboundClientId } outboundTopicConnection.start(); } I'm thinking the above code should check for existence of outboundClientId instead of localClientId Compare this to: protected void initializeLocalTopicConnection() throws NamingException, JMSException { if (localTopicConnection == null) { // get the connection factories if (localTopicConnectionFactory == null) { if (embeddedConnectionFactory == null) { // look it up from JNDI if (localConnectionFactoryName != null) { localTopicConnectionFactory = (TopicConnectionFactory)jndiLocalTemplate .lookup(localConnectionFactoryName, TopicConnectionFactory.class); if (localUsername != null) { localTopicConnection = localTopicConnectionFactory .createTopicConnection(localUsername, localPassword); } else { localTopicConnection = localTopicConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(); } } else { throw new JMSException("Cannot create localConnection - no information"); } } else { localTopicConnection = embeddedConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(); } } else { if (localUsername != null) { localTopicConnection = localTopicConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(localUsername, localPassword); } else { localTopicConnection = localTopicConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(); } } } >>>> if (localClientId != null && localClientId.length() > 0) { // >>>> CHECKS for existence of localClientId localTopicConnection.setClientID(getLocalClientId()); // THEN uses localClientId } localTopicConnection.start(); } > JmsTopicConnector checks for presence of localClientId then uses > outboundClientId > --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- > > Key: AMQ-3635 > URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/AMQ-3635 > Project: ActiveMQ > Issue Type: Bug > Components: Connector > Affects Versions: 5.4.2 > Environment: running 5.4.2 on linux. > Reporter: Jeff Gillings > Priority: Minor > > On the JMS bridge topic connector, if I set the outboundClientId but not the > localClientId, then the outbound client id will not be set. > This is because the JmsTopicConnector only sets the outboundClientId if the > localClientId is set. This appears to be a bug. > Here is 5.4.2 JmsTopicConnector.initializeForeignTopicConnection > {code} > protected void initializeForeignTopicConnection() throws NamingException, > JMSException { > if (outboundTopicConnection == null) { > // get the connection factories > if (outboundTopicConnectionFactory == null) { > // look it up from JNDI > if (outboundTopicConnectionFactoryName != null) { > outboundTopicConnectionFactory = > (TopicConnectionFactory)jndiOutboundTemplate > .lookup(outboundTopicConnectionFactoryName, > TopicConnectionFactory.class); > if (outboundUsername != null) { > outboundTopicConnection = > outboundTopicConnectionFactory > .createTopicConnection(outboundUsername, > outboundPassword); > } else { > outboundTopicConnection = > outboundTopicConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(); > } > } else { > throw new JMSException("Cannot create localConnection - > no information"); > } > } else { > if (outboundUsername != null) { > outboundTopicConnection = outboundTopicConnectionFactory > .createTopicConnection(outboundUsername, > outboundPassword); > } else { > outboundTopicConnection = > outboundTopicConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(); > } > } > } > >>>> if (localClientId != null && localClientId.length() > 0) { > >>>> // CHECKS for existence of localClientId > outboundTopicConnection.setClientID(getOutboundClientId()); > // THEN uses outboundClientId > } > outboundTopicConnection.start(); > } > {code} > I'm thinking the above code should check for existence of outboundClientId > instead of localClientId > Compare this to: > {code} > protected void initializeLocalTopicConnection() throws NamingException, > JMSException { > if (localTopicConnection == null) { > // get the connection factories > if (localTopicConnectionFactory == null) { > if (embeddedConnectionFactory == null) { > // look it up from JNDI > if (localConnectionFactoryName != null) { > localTopicConnectionFactory = > (TopicConnectionFactory)jndiLocalTemplate > .lookup(localConnectionFactoryName, > TopicConnectionFactory.class); > if (localUsername != null) { > localTopicConnection = localTopicConnectionFactory > .createTopicConnection(localUsername, > localPassword); > } else { > localTopicConnection = > localTopicConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(); > } > } else { > throw new JMSException("Cannot create localConnection > - no information"); > } > } else { > localTopicConnection = > embeddedConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(); > } > } else { > if (localUsername != null) { > localTopicConnection = > localTopicConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(localUsername, > > localPassword); > } else { > localTopicConnection = > localTopicConnectionFactory.createTopicConnection(); > } > } > } > >>>> if (localClientId != null && localClientId.length() > 0) { // > >>>> CHECKS for existence of localClientId > localTopicConnection.setClientID(getLocalClientId()); // > THEN uses localClientId > } > localTopicConnection.start(); > } > {code} -- This message is automatically generated by JIRA. If you think it was sent incorrectly, please contact your JIRA administrators: https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/ContactAdministrators!default.jspa For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira