[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/AMQ-5340?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
]
Vermeulen updated AMQ-5340:
---------------------------
Description:
I would expect browsing a queue with only a few messages to not take a long
time. Indeed it normally takes only a few ms. in my application. But sometimes
the ActiveMQQueueBrowser hangs for up to 30 seconds at method before returning!
When the issue occurs, the loop in hasMoreElements() calls waitForMessage()
multiple times which times out after 2s at semaphore.wait(2000) without
receiving any message from the broker. I found that when the broker's
background job that checks for expired messages runs, the browser happens to be
woken even if there are no expired messages. So setting the
expireMessagesPeriod to a low value (e.g. 200ms) is a good workaround for this
issue, but this is quite brittle because it uses internal broker implementation
that may not even be related to the issue!
To reproduce:
- (this is what I do in my application) create a queue, send a few message with
an expiration time of 10 seconds and repeatedly browse it until it is empty. If
I browse the queue after these 10 seconds have passed, the issue occurs!
- I can always reproduce the issue by running AMQ580BrowsingBug from the
related bug report AMQ-4595: this browsing test seems to always hang. I
slightly adjusted the test so you can easily change the expired messages period
and see the runtime differ when changing this.
was:
I would expected browsing a queue with only a few messages to not take take a
long time. Indeed it normally takes only a few ms. in my application. But
sometimes the ActiveMQQueueBrowser hangs for up to 30 seconds at method before
returning!!
When the issue occurs, the loop in hasMoreElements() calls waitForMessage()
multiple times which times out after 2s at semaphore.wait(2000) without
receiving any message from the broker. I found that when the broker's
background job that checks for expired messages runs, the browser happens to be
woken even if there are no expired messages. So setting the
expireMessagesPeriod to a low value (e.g. 200ms) is a good workaround for this
issue, but this is quite brittle because it uses internal broker implementation
that may not even be related to the issue!
To reproduce:
- (this is what I do in my application) create a queue, send a few message with
an expiration time of 10 seconds and repeatedly browse it until it is empty. If
I browse the queue after these 10 seconds have passed, the issue occurs!
- I can always reproduce the issue by running AMQ580BrowsingBug from the
related bug report AMQ-4595: this browsing test seems to always hang. I
slightly adjusted the test so you can easily change the expired messages period
and see the runtime differ with that.
> QueueBrowser hangs until accidentally woken by expired messages background job
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: AMQ-5340
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/AMQ-5340
> Project: ActiveMQ
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: Broker
> Affects Versions: 5.9.0, 5.10.0
> Reporter: Vermeulen
> Priority: Critical
> Labels: QueueBrowser
> Attachments: AMQ5340BrowsingPerformanceBug.java
>
>
> I would expect browsing a queue with only a few messages to not take a long
> time. Indeed it normally takes only a few ms. in my application. But
> sometimes the ActiveMQQueueBrowser hangs for up to 30 seconds at method
> before returning!
> When the issue occurs, the loop in hasMoreElements() calls waitForMessage()
> multiple times which times out after 2s at semaphore.wait(2000) without
> receiving any message from the broker. I found that when the broker's
> background job that checks for expired messages runs, the browser happens to
> be woken even if there are no expired messages. So setting the
> expireMessagesPeriod to a low value (e.g. 200ms) is a good workaround for
> this issue, but this is quite brittle because it uses internal broker
> implementation that may not even be related to the issue!
> To reproduce:
> - (this is what I do in my application) create a queue, send a few message
> with an expiration time of 10 seconds and repeatedly browse it until it is
> empty. If I browse the queue after these 10 seconds have passed, the issue
> occurs!
> - I can always reproduce the issue by running AMQ580BrowsingBug from the
> related bug report AMQ-4595: this browsing test seems to always hang. I
> slightly adjusted the test so you can easily change the expired messages
> period and see the runtime differ when changing this.
--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v6.3.4#6332)
