dev  

Messages by Date

• 2025/06/23 Re: [DISCUSS] What should we cherry-pick ? Pavankumar Gopidesu
• 2025/06/23 Re: [DISCUSS] What should we cherry-pick ? Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/23 Re: [DISCUSS] What should we cherry-pick ? Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/23 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/23 Re: Python 3.13 is coming Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/23 Re: [VOTE] Release Apache Airflow Helm Chart 1.17.0 based on 1.17.0rc2 Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/23 Re: [DISCUSS] Dropping Python 3.9 support Avi
• 2025/06/23 Re: [HELP NEEDED] Cleanup pytest.mark.db_tests Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/23 [Discussion] AIP-90: Should It Be Implemented in the Standard Provider or as a standalone provider? Wei Lee
• 2025/06/23 Re: [Discussion] AIP-90: Should It Be Implemented in the Standard Provider or as a standalone provider? Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/23 Re: [DISCUSS] What should we cherry-pick ? Ash Berlin-Taylor
• 2025/06/23 Re: [VOTE] Release Apache Airflow Helm Chart 1.17.0 based on 1.17.0rc2 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/06/23 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 20, 2025 Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/23 Re: [VOTE] Example dags Jens Scheffler
• 2025/06/23 Re: [DISCUSS] What should we cherry-pick ? Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/23 [DISCUSS] What should we cherry-pick ? Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/23 Re: [DISCUSS] Dropping Python 3.9 support Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/23 Re: [Discussion] AIP-90: Should It Be Implemented in the Standard Provider or as a standalone provider? Wei Lee
• 2025/06/23 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/23 Re: [LAZY CONSENSUS] Dropping Python 3.9 support Elad Kalif
• 2025/06/23 Re: [HELP NEEDED] Cleanup pytest.mark.db_tests Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/23 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Ash Berlin-Taylor
• 2025/06/23 Re: [DISCUSS] Dropping Python 3.9 support Elad Kalif
• 2025/06/23 [LAZY CONSENSUS] Dropping Python 3.9 support Elad Kalif
• 2025/06/23 Re: [DISCUSS] Dropping Python 3.9 support Wei Lee
• 2025/06/23 Re: [DISCUSS] Dropping Python 3.9 support Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/22 Re: [PROPOSAL] Remove creation of real Airflow connections in provider unit tests Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/22 Re: Python 3.13 is coming Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/22 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/22 Re: [VOTE] Release Apache Airflow Helm Chart 1.17.0 based on 1.17.0rc2 Vishnu Chilukoori
• 2025/06/22 Re: [Discussion] AIP-90: Should It Be Implemented in the Standard Provider or as a standalone provider? Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/22 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Vikram Koka
• 2025/06/22 Re: [Discussion] AIP-90: Should It Be Implemented in the Standard Provider or as a standalone provider? Vikram Koka
• 2025/06/22 Re: [Discussion] AIP-90: Should It Be Implemented in the Standard Provider or as a standalone provider? Vikram Koka
• 2025/06/22 Re: [VOTE] Example dags Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/22 [VOTE] Example dags Jens Scheffler
• 2025/06/22 Re: [LAZY,CONSENSUS] Example dags Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/22 [LAZY,CONSENSUS] Example dags Jens Scheffler
• 2025/06/22 Re: [VOTE] Example dags Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/22 Re: [VOTE] Release Apache Airflow Helm Chart 1.17.0 based on 1.17.0rc2 Jens Scheffler
• 2025/06/22 [HELP NEEDED] Cleanup pytest.mark.db_tests Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/22 Re: [DISCUSS] Dropping Python 3.9 support Pavankumar Gopidesu
• 2025/06/22 Re: [DISCUSS] Dropping Python 3.9 support Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/22 [DISCUSS] Dropping Python 3.9 support Elad Kalif
• 2025/06/22 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Pavankumar Gopidesu
• 2025/06/22 Re: [DISCUSS] Possible Werkzeug vulnerabilities fix for Airflow 2 (Connexion 2.15.0rc1) Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/21 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Jens Scheffler
• 2025/06/21 Re: [VOTE] Release Apache Airflow Helm Chart 1.17.0 based on 1.17.0rc2 Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/21 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/21 Re: [VOTE] Release Apache Airflow Helm Chart 1.17.0 based on 1.17.0rc2 Shahar Epstein
• 2025/06/20 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 20, 2025 Shahar Epstein
• 2025/06/20 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 20, 2025 Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/20 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 20, 2025 Jens Scheffler
• 2025/06/20 [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 20, 2025 Elad Kalif
• 2025/06/20 Python 3.13 is coming Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/19 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/19 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Oliveira, Niko
• 2025/06/19 Re: OpenTelemetry PR review Christos Bisias
• 2025/06/19 Re: OpenTelemetry PR review Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/19 OpenTelemetry PR review Christos Bisias
• 2025/06/19 Re: [LAZY CONSENSUS] Add French Translation (i18n) Pierre Jeambrun
• 2025/06/19 Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow official MCP Server Shahar Epstein
• 2025/06/19 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/19 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/18 Re: [DISCUSS] Possible Werkzeug vulnerabilities fix for Airflow 2 (Connexion 2.15.0rc1) Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/18 Re: [Result][VOTE] Adding @RoyLee1224 @guan404ming as Non-Committer Translation Owners and @jason810496 as both a Code Owner and Translation Owner GUAN-MING CHIU
• 2025/06/18 [Result][VOTE] Adding @RoyLee1224 @guan404ming as Non-Committer Translation Owners and @jason810496 as both a Code Owner and Translation Owner Wei Lee
• 2025/06/18 [VOTE] Release Apache Airflow Helm Chart 1.17.0 based on 1.17.0rc2 Jed Cunningham
• 2025/06/18 Re: [DISCUSS] Possible Werkzeug vulnerabilities fix for Airflow 2 (Connexion 2.15.0rc1) Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/18 Re: [VOTE] Adding @RoyLee1224 @guan404ming as Non-Committer Translation Owners and @jason810496 as both a Code Owner and Translation Owner Vishnu Chilukoori
• 2025/06/18 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 15, 2025 Vishnu Chilukoori
• 2025/06/18 Re: [DISCUSS] Possible Werkzeug vulnerabilities fix for Airflow 2 (Connexion 2.15.0rc1) Kamil Breguła
• 2025/06/18 Re: [VOTE] Release Apache Airflow Helm Chart 1.17.0 based on 1.17.0rc1 Jed Cunningham
• 2025/06/18 [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow Providers prepared on June 15, 2025 are released Elad Kalif
• 2025/06/18 [RESULT][VOTE] Airflow Providers - release of June 15, 2025 Elad Kalif
• 2025/06/18 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 15, 2025 Elad Kalif
• 2025/06/17 Re: [DISCUSS] Possible Werkzeug vulnerabilities fix for Airflow 2 (Connexion 2.15.0rc1) Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/17 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Oliveira, Niko
• 2025/06/17 Re: [LAZY CONSENSUS] Add French Translation (i18n) Shahar Epstein
• 2025/06/17 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 15, 2025 Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/17 Re: [DISCUSS] Apache Airflow official MCP Server Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/17 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 15, 2025 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/06/17 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 15, 2025 Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/17 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 15, 2025 Ash Berlin-Taylor
• 2025/06/17 Re: [LAZY CONSENSUS] Add French Translation (i18n) Pierre Jeambrun
• 2025/06/16 [VOTE] Release Apache Airflow Helm Chart 1.17.0 based on 1.17.0rc1 Jed Cunningham
• 2025/06/16 Re: [LAZY CONSENSUS] Add French Translation (i18n) Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/16 Re: [LAZY CONSENSUS] Add French Translation (i18n) Elad Kalif
• 2025/06/16 Re: [LAZY CONSENSUS] Add French Translation (i18n) Pierre Jeambrun
• 2025/06/16 [LAZY CONSENSUS] Add French Translation (i18n) Pierre Jeambrun
• 2025/06/16 Re: [LAZY CONSENSUS] Adding @TJaniF @m1racoli as Non-Committer Translation Owners Tamara Fingerlin
• 2025/06/15 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 15, 2025 Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/15 Re: [LAZY CONCENSUS] Adding Hussein Awala as a Code Owner & Translation Owner Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/15 Re: [VOTE] Adding @RoyLee1224 @guan404ming as Non-Committer Translation Owners and @jason810496 as both a Code Owner and Translation Owner Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/15 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Jens Scheffler
• 2025/06/15 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 15, 2025 Jens Scheffler
• 2025/06/15 [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 15, 2025 Elad Kalif
• 2025/06/14 Re: [LAZY CONCENSUS] Adding Hussein Awala as a Code Owner & Translation Owner GUAN-MING CHIU
• 2025/06/14 Re: [LAZY CONCENSUS] Adding Hussein Awala as a Code Owner & Translation Owner Wei Lee
• 2025/06/14 Re: [VOTE] Adding @RoyLee1224 @guan404ming as Non-Committer Translation Owners and @jason810496 as both a Code Owner and Translation Owner Shahar Epstein
• 2025/06/14 Re: [LAZY CONCENSUS] Adding Hussein Awala as a Code Owner & Translation Owner Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/14 Re: [LAZY CONCENSUS] Adding Hussein Awala as a Code Owner & Translation Owner Brent Bovenzi
• 2025/06/14 Re: [VOTE] Adding @RoyLee1224 @guan404ming as Non-Committer Translation Owners and @jason810496 as both a Code Owner and Translation Owner Brent Bovenzi
• 2025/06/14 Re: [VOTE] Adding @RoyLee1224 @guan404ming as Non-Committer Translation Owners and @jason810496 as both a Code Owner and Translation Owner Jens Scheffler
• 2025/06/14 Re: [VOTE] Adding @RoyLee1224 @guan404ming as Non-Committer Translation Owners and @jason810496 as both a Code Owner and Translation Owner GUAN-MING CHIU
• 2025/06/14 Re: [VOTE] Adding @RoyLee1224 @guan404ming as Non-Committer Translation Owners and @jason810496 as both a Code Owner and Translation Owner Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/14 Re: [VOTE] Adding @RoyLee1224 @guan404ming as Non-Committer Translation Owners and @jason810496 as both a Code Owner and Translation Owner Wei Lee
• 2025/06/14 Re: [VOTE] Adding @RoyLee1224 @guan404ming as Non-Committer Translation Owners and @jason810496 as both a Code Owner and Translation Owner Zhe You Liu
• 2025/06/14 [VOTE] Adding @RoyLee1224 @guan404ming as Non-Committer Translation Owners and @jason810496 as both a Code Owner and Translation Owner Wei Lee
• 2025/06/14 [LAZY CONCENSUS] Adding Hussein Awala as a Code Owner & Translation Owner Shahar Epstein
• 2025/06/14 Re: [LAZY CONSENSUS] Adding @TJaniF @m1racoli as Non-Committer Translation Owners Shahar Epstein
• 2025/06/13 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/13 Re: [LAZY CONSENSUS] Adding @TJaniF @m1racoli as Non-Committer Translation Owners Jens Scheffler
• 2025/06/13 [ANNOUNCEMENT] Looking for potential new security team members Elad Kalif
• 2025/06/13 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Vincent Beck
• 2025/06/13 [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow Python Client 3.0.2 Released Kaxil Naik
• 2025/06/13 [RESULT][VOTE] Release Apache Airflow Python Client 3.0.2 from 3.0.2rc1 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/06/13 [DISCUSS] Possible Werkzeug vulnerabilities fix for Airflow 2 (Connexion 2.15.0rc1) Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/13 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/12 Re: [DISCUSS] Persisting State in a Trigger Karen Braganza
• 2025/06/12 Re: [DISCUSS] Persisting State in a Trigger Daniel Standish
• 2025/06/12 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/12 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Ash Berlin-Taylor
• 2025/06/12 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Bishundeo, Rajeshwar
• 2025/06/12 Re: [DISCUSS] DB changes to support multi-team Ash Berlin-Taylor
• 2025/06/12 Re: [VOTE] Release Apache Airflow Python Client 3.0.2 from 3.0.2rc1 Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/12 Re: Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/12 Re: [DISCUSS] DB changes to support multi-team Vincent Beck
• 2025/06/12 Re: [DISCUSS] Persisting State in a Trigger Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/12 Discuss: AIP-67 (multi team) now that AIP-82 (External event driven dags) exists Ash Berlin-Taylor
• 2025/06/12 Re: [RESULT] AIP-90 Human in the loop Vishnu Chilukoori
• 2025/06/12 Re: [DISCUSS] DB changes to support multi-team Ash Berlin-Taylor
• 2025/06/12 Re: [DISCUSS] DB changes to support multi-team Ash Berlin-Taylor
• 2025/06/12 Re: [DISCUSS] DB changes to support multi-team Ash Berlin-Taylor
• 2025/06/11 Re: [VOTE] AIP-90 Human in the loop Ash Berlin-Taylor
• 2025/06/11 [RESULT] AIP-90 Human in the loop Ash Berlin-Taylor
• 2025/06/11 Re: [DISCUSS] Persisting State in a Trigger Ash Berlin-Taylor
• 2025/06/10 Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.0.2 Released Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/10 [LAZY CONSENSUS] Adding @TJaniF @m1racoli as Non-Committer Translation Owners Jens Scheffler
• 2025/06/10 Re: [VOTE] Release Apache Airflow Python Client 3.0.2 from 3.0.2rc1 Jens Scheffler
• 2025/06/10 [VOTE] Release Apache Airflow Python Client 3.0.2 from 3.0.2rc1 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/06/10 Re: [DISCUSS] Persisting State in a Trigger Ryan Hatter
• 2025/06/10 Re: [DISCUSS] Persisting State in a Trigger Ryan Hatter
• 2025/06/10 Re: [Lazy Concensus] Naming tweak in Deadlines table Kalyan Reddy
• 2025/06/10 [ANNOUNCE] Recording: June 2025 Airflow Monthly Town Hall Briana Okyere
• 2025/06/10 [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow 3.0.2 Released Kaxil Naik
• 2025/06/10 Re: [DISCUSS] DB changes to support multi-team Vincent Beck
• 2025/06/10 Re: [DISCUSS] DB changes to support multi-team Vincent Beck
• 2025/06/10 [RESULT][VOTE] Release Airflow 3.0.2 from 3.0.2rc2 & Task SDK 1.0.2 from 1.0.2rc2 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/06/10 Re: [VOTE] Release Airflow 3.0.2 from 3.0.2rc2 & Task SDK 1.0.2 from 1.0.2rc2 Ephraim Anierobi
• 2025/06/09 Re: [VOTE] Release Airflow 3.0.2 from 3.0.2rc2 & Task SDK 1.0.2 from 1.0.2rc2 Wei Lee
• 2025/06/09 Re: [VOTE] Release Airflow 3.0.2 from 3.0.2rc2 & Task SDK 1.0.2 from 1.0.2rc2 Rahul Vats
• 2025/06/09 [RESULT][VOTE] Internationalization (i18n) policy Shahar Epstein
• 2025/06/09 Re: [VOTE] AIP-90 Human in the loop Bas Harenslak
• 2025/06/09 Re: [VOTE] AIP-90 Human in the loop Jed Cunningham
• 2025/06/09 Re: [VOTE] AIP-90 Human in the loop Shubham Raj
• 2025/06/09 Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow Providers prepared on June 03, 2025 are released Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/09 [DISCUSS] DB changes to support multi-team Beck, Vincent
• 2025/06/09 Re: [DISCUSS] Persisting State in a Trigger Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/09 Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow Providers prepared on June 03, 2025 are released Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/09 Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow Providers prepared on June 03, 2025 are released Kaxil Naik
• 2025/06/08 Re: [VOTE] Release Airflow 3.0.2 from 3.0.2rc2 & Task SDK 1.0.2 from 1.0.2rc2 Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/08 Re: [VOTE] Release Airflow 3.0.2 from 3.0.2rc2 & Task SDK 1.0.2 from 1.0.2rc2 Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/07 Re: [VOTE] Release Airflow 3.0.2 from 3.0.2rc2 & Task SDK 1.0.2 from 1.0.2rc2 Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/07 [ANNOUNCE] Apache Airflow Providers prepared on June 03, 2025 are released Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/07 [RESULT][VOTE] Airflow Providers - release of June 03, 2025 Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/07 Re: [VOTE] Release Airflow 3.0.2 from 3.0.2rc2 & Task SDK 1.0.2 from 1.0.2rc2 Jens Scheffler
• 2025/06/07 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 03, 2025 Elad Kalif
• 2025/06/07 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 03, 2025 Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/06 Re: [VOTE] AIP-90 Human in the loop Vishnu Chilukoori
• 2025/06/06 [VOTE] Release Airflow 3.0.2 from 3.0.2rc2 & Task SDK 1.0.2 from 1.0.2rc2 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/06/06 [CANCELLED][VOTE] Release Airflow 3.0.2 from 3.0.2rc1 & Task SDK 1.0.2 from 1.0.2rc1 Kaxil Naik
• 2025/06/06 Re: [VOTE] Internationalization (i18n) policy kalyan reddy
• 2025/06/05 Re: [VOTE] Internationalization (i18n) policy Ephraim Anierobi
• 2025/06/05 Re: [VOTE] Release Airflow 3.0.2 from 3.0.2rc1 & Task SDK 1.0.2 from 1.0.2rc1 Wei Lee
• 2025/06/05 [Meeting Notes] Airflow 3 dev call - 5 June 2025 Vikram Koka
• 2025/06/05 Re: [VOTE] Internationalization (i18n) policy Pavankumar Gopidesu
• 2025/06/05 Re: [VOTE] AIP-90 Human in the loop Pavankumar Gopidesu
• 2025/06/05 Re: [VOTE] AIP-90 Human in the loop Ash Berlin-Taylor
• 2025/06/05 Re: [DISCUSS] Upcoming FAB 5 (we have a green PR!) needs more eyes Vincent Beck
• 2025/06/05 Re: [VOTE] Internationalization (i18n) policy Pierre Jeambrun
• 2025/06/05 Re: [VOTE] Internationalization (i18n) policy Wei Lee
• 2025/06/05 Re: [VOTE] Internationalization (i18n) policy Tamara Fingerlin
• 2025/06/05 Re: Re: [VOTE] AIP-90 Human in the loop Buğra Öztürk
• 2025/06/05 Re: [VOTE] Internationalization (i18n) policy Buğra Öztürk
• 2025/06/05 Re: Re: [VOTE] AIP-90 Human in the loop Tamara Fingerlin
• 2025/06/05 [DISCUSS] Upcoming FAB 5 (we have a green PR!) needs more eyes Jarek Potiuk
• 2025/06/05 RE: Re: [VOTE] AIP-90 Human in the loop 邱冠銘
• 2025/06/05 RE: [VOTE] Internationalization (i18n) policy GUAN-MING CHIU
• 2025/06/05 RE: Re: [VOTE] Internationalization (i18n) policy GUAN-MING CHIU
• 2025/06/05 Re: [VOTE] AIP-90 Human in the loop Ephraim Anierobi
• 2025/06/04 Re: [VOTE] AIP-90 Human in the loop Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/04 Re: [VOTE] Internationalization (i18n) policy Amogh Desai
• 2025/06/04 Re: [VOTE] AIP-90 Human in the loop Rahul Vats
• 2025/06/04 Re: [VOTE] AIP-90 Human in the loop Phani Kumar
• 2025/06/04 Re: [VOTE] AIP-90 Human in the loop kalyan reddy
• 2025/06/04 Re: [VOTE] Airflow Providers prepared on June 03, 2025 Jens Scheffler
• 2025/06/04 Re: [VOTE] Internationalization (i18n) policy Ahmad Farhan
• 2025/06/04 Re: [VOTE] Internationalization (i18n) policy Brent Bovenzi
• 2025/06/04 Re: [VOTE] Internationalization (i18n) policy Aritra Basu

• Earlier messages