jay vyas created BIGTOP-1431:
--------------------------------

             Summary: Determine future of Kerberos and ID Support in BigTop
                 Key: BIGTOP-1431
                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/BIGTOP-1431
             Project: Bigtop
          Issue Type: Task
            Reporter: jay vyas


We might need to address kerberization and identity management at some point in 
bigtop...

-  A concrete reason is that the new hadoop versions require kerberos for use 
of the LinuxContainerExecutor (alterantive to default yarn container executor 
which just spins up a new JVM - LCE actually logs in as the user submitting the 
job , and runs with user permissions at the posix level).

- Non HDFS FileSystems require posix identities, not just user name strings 
like HDFS.  So to securely support HDFS alternatives in yarn jobs, linux 
containers are required.

- Another reason is that enterprises and so on are moving towards first class 
ID management with hadoop.  We can leverage existing identity management 
tooling to make this a reality in bigtop as well, .

[~plinnell] and [~cos] I think FreeIPA makes it super easy to use DNS + LDAP + 
Kerberos together.    And I think in the enterprise, We will see increasing 
number of folks wanting to use it in their hadoop workloads.     We've already 
seen how hbase DNS can be tricky anyways.  So, I actually think a FreeIPA 
enabled bigtop distro might be a pretty valuable artifact for the community.    
In any case, I 

Now... Cos has mentioned some other intriguing ideas around YARN as well.  In 
any case, lets hash out how Identities and kerberos should be managed , if at 
all, in bigtop.



--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v6.3.4#6332)

Reply via email to