Thanks for clarifying. Overall sounds good to me! +1 If no objection, you can take this as a silence agreement from other community members.
Yuqi Gu <[email protected]>於 2019年5月17日 週五，下午5:53寫道： > Hi Evans, > > Really thanks for your comments! > > >>* What kind of change do you expect in patch3-AMBARI-bigtop-mpack.diff?* > > > > * Is it served like a mpack selector to override the default > mpack(probabaly CDH/HDP) released by Ambari? A general idea is we > tend not to add patches in Bigtop. A better way is to patch in upstream, > unless it's more reasonable to reside in Bigtop.* > I'm not sure whether Ambari guys will show interests in Bigtop-mpack or > not, so it may take long time to put the patch in Ambari upstream. > 'patch3-AMBARI-bigtop-mpack.diff' is the temporary copy of the > 'Bigtop-Mpack' patch which would be submitted to Ambari upstream. > It also can be used to add the new feature of Bigtop-Mpack in Bigtop 1.4.0 > release or in 1.5.0 release. > When 'Bigtop-mpack' is merged by Ambari upstream, we will remove it from > Bigtop. > > >> *I think we can just add a task in package.gradle that will tar all the* > * required scripts for Bigtop mpack. Simple is better.* > Yeah, it makes sense. > > BRs, > Yuqi > > > > > > > On Tue, 14 May 2019 at 19:52, Evans Ye <[email protected]> wrote: > > > Hey Yugi, > > > > Thanks for bringing up the discussion. Overall I think the proposal looks > > good. > > Questions though, > > > > | 3. Put the Bigtop-Mpack patch in 'bigtop-packages/src/common/ambari' as > > 'patch3-AMBARI-bigtop-mpack.diff'. > > What kind of change do you expect in patch3-AMBARI-bigtop-mpack.diff? > > Is it served like a mpack selector to override the default > mpack(probabaly > > CDH/HDP) released by Ambari? > > A general idea is we tend not to add patches in Bigtop. A better way is > to > > patch in upstream, unless it's more reasonable to reside in Bigtop. > > > > | 4. Modify the Bigtop scripts related for releasing Bigtop-mpack tarball > > for users > > I think we can just add a task in package.gradle that will tar all the > > required scripts for Bigtop mpack. Simple is better. > > > > For other's who'd like to know more about the RFC: > > https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/BIGTOP-3211 > > > > Best, > > Evans > > > > > > > > Yuqi Gu <[email protected]> 於 2019年5月14日 週二 下午7:22寫道： > > > > > Hi folks, > > > > > > I'd like to propose a new Ambari Mpack for Bigtop, which is described > in > > > BIGTOP-3211. > > > (Also see in: RFCs for Bigtop-mpack > > > < > > > > > > https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/attachment/12967363/RFCs%20for%20Bigtop-mpack.pdf > > > > > > > ) > > > > > > Ambari is a Apache project to make Hadoop management simpler. > > > Bigtop Mpack uses Ambari management pack to add management capability > for > > > Bigtop components packages. > > > It can significantly improve the efficiency on deployment and > management > > of > > > Bigtop components and give convenience to > > > the Bigtop users who'd like to adopt Bigtop-Ambari to deploy and > manager > > > other Bigtop components such as Hadoop, Spark,Hive, etc. > > > > > > How-to-achieve-it: > > > 1. Contribute the Bigtop-Mpack to Apache Ambari based on its latest > > release > > > 2.7.3. > > > 2. Upgrade the Ambari from 2.6.1 to 2.7.3 in Bigtop. > > > 3. Put the Bigtop-Mpack patch in 'bigtop-packages/src/common/ambari' as > > > 'patch3-AMBARI-bigtop-mpack.diff'. > > > 4. Modify the Bigtop scripts related for releasing Bigtop-mpack tarball > > for > > > users > > > > > > Any comments are appreciated and welcome! > > > Thanks! > > > > > > BRs, > > > Yuqi > > > > > >
