Jose, Thanks for that. Can you open a jira task to track this issue properly and add the jira issue url in this thread later on?
There are a couple of workaround to ypur problem: 1. Can you try a list of required.ports: - 22 - 8082 in the provisioning.properties of your entity? 2. Alternatively, can you just use the default 8081, maybe? Thanks, Andrea Andrea Il 05/mag/2016 03:49, "Jose Carrasco" <jo...@lcc.uma.es> ha scritto: > Hi all, > > I tried to deploy a BrooklynNode entity with an explicit web console port > (8082) over a AWS VM machine. Using the following plan: > > name: BrooklynNode > location: > jclouds:aws-ec2: > region: us-west-2 > identity: **** > credential: **** > services: > - type: org.apache.brooklyn.entity.brooklynnode.BrooklynNode > id: brooklynNode > name: brooklynNode > brooklyn.config: > onExistingProperties: do_not_use > brooklynnode.webconsole.nosecurity: true > brooklynnode.webconsole.httpPort: 8082 > > However I found an error because the entity did not look to be up ( > SERVICE_UP retrieved false). Then, I tried to figure out a bit. The > BrooklynNode instance was installed and executed correctly but the VM’s > security group did not have any rule to enable the 8082 port. It looks that > the problem is here [1], the following if code condition: > > (PortRange.class.isAssignableFrom(k.getType()) || > portsPattern.matcher(k.getName()).matches()) > > returns false because when the BrooklynNode.HTTPS_PORT is evaluated the > entity is not assignable from PortRange because the config key instance > is retrieved by [2], which returns a ConfigKey<Object>, so the type is > not assignable from PortRange.class. > Moreover, the config key name is brooklynnode.webconsole.httpPort, which > is not matchable by the portPattern “*.port”. > Then, the port that is specified from BrooklynNode.HTTPS_PORT config key > is not evaluated as a PortRange config key, and it is not returned by > getRequiredOpenPorts() method. Then you can see that the VM does not > contains the necessary flags [3] to open the specified http port, so as > result the *Brooklyn node web console* is not accesible. > I have seen that there is a test which check the BrooklynNode.HTTPS_PORT > in BrooklynNodeIntegrationTest [4], but (I think) different ports are > tested over the local machine where all ports are accessible. > > If you consider that this behavior should be solved, I have two different > proposal. > > - First, adapting the BrooklynNode.HTTPS_PORT name to the > portPattern, so “brooklynnode.webconsole.httpPort” should be replaced > by “brooklynnode.webconsole.http.port”. I think it is the best option. > (it should be necessary review the rest of config keys too). > - Modify the InboundPortsUtils#getRequiredOpenPorts method in order to > support config keys whose value is assignable from PortRange. In this > case I have written a little commit [commit]. > > > I would like to solve this issue. > Thought? > > Please, note that if you configure the BrooklynNode.HTTPS_PORT pointing to > 8081 (default value) the web console will be not accessible because the > configuration follows the same process that 8082 scenario. > If no port is defined, the 8081 will be accessible because config keys > will be retrieved by the entityType [5] that provides the default entities’ > ConfigKeys whose types will be assignable from PortRange.class. > > Jose > GSoC student > > [1] > https://github.com/apache/brooklyn-server/blob/9b0fe8a6d1766728753e0d3ae7bf7c87602a443a/software/base/src/main/java/org/apache/brooklyn/entity/software/base/InboundPortsUtils.java#L85 > > [2] > https://github.com/apache/brooklyn-server/blob/9b0fe8a6d1766728753e0d3ae7bf7c87602a443a/software/base/src/main/java/org/apache/brooklyn/entity/software/base/InboundPortsUtils.java#L80 > > [3] > https://github.com/apache/brooklyn-server/blob/9b0fe8a6d1766728753e0d3ae7bf7c87602a443a/software/base/src/main/java/org/apache/brooklyn/entity/software/base/lifecycle/MachineLifecycleEffectorTasks.java#L374 > > [4] > https://github.com/apache/brooklyn-server/blob/9b0fe8a6d1766728753e0d3ae7bf7c87602a443a/software/base/src/test/java/org/apache/brooklyn/entity/brooklynnode/BrooklynNodeIntegrationTest.java > > [commit] > https://github.com/kiuby88/brooklyn-server/commit/06086c346719abe9c9162dce773677d2abad5d05 > > [5] > https://github.com/apache/brooklyn-server/blob/9b0fe8a6d1766728753e0d3ae7bf7c87602a443a/software/base/src/main/java/org/apache/brooklyn/entity/software/base/InboundPortsUtils.java#L78 > >
