Thanks Hadrian for trying this out and giving your feedback. On 12 December 2014 at 14:59, Hadrian Zbarcea <[email protected]> wrote: > +1 (binding) contingent on noting the issues below and following up with > another rc soon-ish.
Could you help me with a point about incubator votes? I notice that your vote is "binding", and that you are on the IPMC. I had assumed that on this vote (to dev@brooklyn list) binding votes were only from the Brooklyn PPMC, including the Brooklyn mentors. Is it the case that an IPMC member can always issue binding votes wherever a PPMC can? Not that this is a complaint of course - the more binding votes the better :-) > 3. Build from source distro without running tests gives an error [3] I'm not aware of this error and I haven't been able to reproduce it myself - would you be able to file a bug report and/or post to the Brooklyn list with some more information? > 4. Build from source distro and running tests gives another error [4], I > think it is known one. Yes this one is known and is fixed on the master branch. The problem is that the release has taken a while so far, so the release branch is now missing several fixes that are on master. If you believe that this issue is important enough, then we should be able to cherry-pick this bug into the release branch (there is likely to be another rc before we take this to the general@incubator list for their vote) > 5. Sources are in the "brooklyn" package, I think moving to > "org.apache.brooklyn" would be a mandatory prerequisite for graduation. > Easier to get it done earlier. Yes, this is something that we were aware of that needs to be addressed before graduation. It's something that needs to be planned carefully because it can cause significant disruption to our community, by breaking the builds of anybody who has written their own integrations for Brooklyn. Thanks again for taking the time to do this! Richard.
