After a quick discussion with james,
This vote is canceled.
We will work to fix these issues one by one.
BTW: Justin, add a progress disclaimer and make a release,
Does it still need go through two stage of vote process?
If So, is it an apache release but with some known issue?
Thanks again for your review.
在 2020/1/3 上午11:15，“tan zhongyi”<[email protected]> 写入:
Thanks, Justin,
We will check it carefully.
On 2020/01/03 01:04:56, Justin Mclean
<[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:
> Hi,>
>
> Some of us are not guys :-)>
>
> I’m -1 (binding) for three reasons:>
> - the artefact names must include "incubating “ but this can be easily
fixed and the voting doesn’t need to restarted (if this was the only issue)>
> - but it also contains category B code [2] under the CDDL license.>
> - and it also contains category X code [9] under the GPL license.>
>
> you may want to consider using the work in progress disclaimer while you
sort these issues out. [11]>
>
> I checked:>
> - incubating not in name>
> - DISCLAIMER exists>
> - LICENSE is missing appendix>
> - NOTICE year needs to be updated>
> - Source release contains category B code which is not allowed [2]>
> - Source release contains Category X software which is not allowed. [9]>
> - All ASF source files have ASF headers>
> - No unexpected binary files>
>
> I did a spot check on licenses in LICENSE and it look like it missing a
few things:>
> - SVGPan library 1.2 Copyright 2009-2010 Andrea Leofredd contain within
[3]>
> - This file written by Colin Plumb >
> - Supporting functions within this file by Dean Edwards of unknown
license.>
> - Code Copyright (c) 2006-2013 Alexander Chemeris in these files [6][7]>
> - MPEG2 transport stream Copyright (c) 2003 Fabrice Bellard in his file.
[8] This is category X and can’t be included in a source release.>
> - This file [10] is list as copyright Tencent when it actually Copyright
(c) 2013, The TOFT Authors.>
>
> Thanks,>
> Justin>
>
> 1. src/brpc/builtin/flamegraph_perl.cpp>
> 2. https://www.apache.org/legal/resolved.html#weak-copyleft-licenses>
> 3. ./src/brpc/builtin/pprof_perl.cpp>
> 4. ./src/butil/md5.cc>
> 5. ./src/brpc/builtin/sorttable_js.cpp>
> 6. ./src/butil/third_party/rapidjson/msinttypes/inttypes.h>
> 7. ./src/butil/third_party/rapidjson/msinttypes/stdint.h>
> 8../src/brpc/ts.cpp>
> 9. https://www.apache.org/legal/resolved.html#category-x>
> 10. src/butil/memory/scoped_array.h>
> 11. https://incubator.apache.org/policy/incubation.html#disclaimers>
> --------------------------------------------------------------------->
> To unsubscribe, e-mail:
[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>>
> For additional commands, e-mail:
[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>>
>
>
