On 11.12.2014 07:32, Claus Ibsen wrote:
And frankly a camel-http-core would maybe also be good, which has no
or only dependency on the servlet api. Then there can be some shared
code that the various HTTP components can rely and reuse.
Yes it would avoid that we depend on camel-http which brings in unwanted
additional dependencies. On the other hand it would add one more module.
I hope we can manage the embedding.
It might be a bit problematic as we need to export the shared classes.
Probably it can work if we also import them. We will have to experiment
with it.
As a next step we should then define the separation between the modules. The
last step would then be to implement the three modules.
For the karaf feature I plan to use the new conditional descriptors to
install the correct module depending on the karaf runtime. So for karaf 2.4
and 3 it should install the jetty8 one and for karaf 4 it should install the
jetty 9 one.
Both of the modules would be installed with the same feature camel-jetty and
the same prefix jetty: . So this should minimize the impact on users. This
approach should also allow us to work with an upcoming jetty 10.
Sounds good. Is that a karaf 4 only thing?
The conditionals should be available for karaf >= 2.4 so we should be
able to cover all supported karaf versions with the feature file. It
will then definately exclude karaf < 2.4 though but I think that should
be ok.
Do we all agree that on camel master we only need to support jetty 8 and 9
and can safely remove jetty 7 support as Dan has already done?
Yes jetty 7 can and should be dropped/removed
What about CXF, what versions of Jetty does it support?
Does CXF 3.0.x support both jetty 8 and 9?
CXF 3.0 supports jetty 7 and 8 as far as I know.
CXF 3.1 will support jetty 8 and 9. So we should use karaf >= 3 with a
cxf >= 3.1 and the camel version that supports jetty 8 and 9 for smx.
eg so we can do a SMX release with Camel 2.15 + CXF 3.0.x + Karaf 3.0
+ AMQ 5.11 and they all live happy together with the same version of
Jetty
ActiveMQ 5.11 may need to be made jetty 8 + 9 compatible also.
Most of activemq 5.10 already works with karaf 4 (jetty 9). The main
problem is the rest API which needs to be updated.
Christian
--
Christian Schneider
http://www.liquid-reality.de
Open Source Architect
http://www.talend.com
