Sylvain Wallez dijo: > Rolf Kulemann wrote: > >>On Thu, 2004-09-16 at 19:55, Hunsberger, Peter wrote: >> >> >>>Tim Larson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: >>> >>> >>> >>>>This is a lazy poll to see if I should commit the >>>>cforms-based editor for sitemaps, xreports, cforms, and any >>>>other xml files. >>>> >>>>It is nowhere near production-ready, has a security hole in >>>>it (so don't put it on an exposed server yet), has >>>>copy-and-paste bugs all through it, and it does not enforce >>>>the various schemas very well yet because it is still under >>>>heavy development... However, several people have expressed >>>>interest in seeing the code and possibly even helping with >>>>the implementation :) >>>> >>>>So to summarize, I am willing to swallow my pride and commit >>>>this "ugly duckling" code if it is ok to create a temporary >>>>branch for it in svn so we can more easily work together to >>>>finish the implementation. MrTompkins has graciously offered >>>>the codename "swan" to use for the branch name, which I think >>>>is rather fitting considering the transformation I expect it >>>>to undergo once we get more people working on it ;) >>>> >>>> >>>I'm not sure why you need a SVN branch as opposed to just adding a new >>>block? >>> >>> >> >>Maybe the "new feature" is not isolated enough e.g. it will affect the >>cforms block. I dunno exactly, but that is how I understood it. >> >> > > If it affects the cforms block because of the need for new features, > then that is a good thing, as Tim's use case is a very advanced one that > could be beneficial to all CForms users. > > And placing the particular use of these features (sitemap editor, etc) > in a separate block allows to isolate them from the main CForms core, > which is a good thing also, unless they could be simply considered as > advanced samples and thus placed in forms/samples. > > Finally, unless this required a major rewrite of CForm, I don't see the > need for a separate branch. > > So go on and commit, Tim!
+1 To be committed as a sample, if you don't need nothing more. Best Regards, Antonio Gallardo
