Re: RFC: CForms + Dojo: the way forward

[Jeremy Quinn]

On 6 Oct 2006, at 21:45, Jean-Baptiste Quenot wrote:

Hello Jeremy,

Ah, Monsieur Querty ;)

This is a nice CForms roadmap indeed.  See my comment below:

Thanks to all those who took part .....

* Jeremy Quinn:

3. We have  two templating systems, there  are incompatibilities
between them and different capabilities, can we deprecate one?

Conclusion: the  JXMacro generation  technique seems to  be more
popular and capable. We should if  possible deprecate the use of
the FormsTransformer,  adding any  missing functionality  to the
JXMacro lib. Before we decide this,  we need an accurate idea of
all compatibility  and any  performance differences  between the
two. We need to write some docs explaining the migration path.

The old  JXTemplateGenerator is the cause  of performance problems
when  using  the  CForms's   JX  macros.   So  deprecating  CForms
transformer also means switching from the old JXTG to the new one.

Does anyone know how much faster it is ?

By old and new, do you mean :

  old : org.apache.cocoon.generation.JXTemplateGenerator

  new : org.apache.cocoon.template.JXTemplateGenerator



Many thanks for your response

regards Jeremy

Is the new JXTG ready to switch to, so that the old one may be deprecated ? Anyone who manages to test the speed difference, please report back to this thread .....

smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME cryptographic signature