On Feb 13, 2014, at 10:04 AM, Jonathan Bond-Caron <jbo...@gdesolutions.com> 
wrote:

> IBM most likely would prefer XML for the XSD & tooling…

Not necessarily. Schema validation is nice, but XML for the sake of XML doesn't 
make sense. What makes more sense is following standards where reasonably 
possible. But if the widget spec is deprecated and we are making a conscious 
decision to abandon it, then the leaning for XML goes away. Given the audience 
of web devs, and the use of json config in other places, my preference would be 
for json config. However, getting there in a way that is not disruptive to app 
devs and their existing apps is really important.

> Note about xml vs. json config, Cordova could support both.

Cordova could, but that seems to me like overkill. If someone really wants xml, 
how about providing an xslt that translates the xml to json, so they can author 
in xml and Cordova could read json. But even that sounds like overkill too.

But if the attraction of xml is schema validation, then perhaps that could be 
taken care of with http://json-schema.org/

Reply via email to