General remark: My sense is that an assessment against the ASF maturity model is in addition to other requirements for graduation from the incubator.
Also, the footnotes matter. The Model is meant to be generic, which is why it does not go down to specifics about libraries, etc. I also think that it will be very ASF-friendly if assessment remarks simply declare how a particular element is taken to apply, and where supporting information about further details is found. - Dennis [ ... ] > On 9 Aug 2015, at 11:20 pm, jan i <j...@apache.org> wrote: > > Hi. > > I just spent a few hours having fun. > > I made a wiki page, with the maturity model > https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/Corinthia/The+Apache+Project+Maturity+Model > > Actually quite an interesting job. Please have a look at my responses, and > let us see where we > end up. > > I found some of the questions, directly wrong or at the very least > misleading. I also lacked some questions about how the community is > actually doing. > > My intention is to see your reactions (and incorporate that), and then > start a new discussion on general@ because if this is something podlings > should fill up, some of the questions need to > be changed or better documented. > > rgds > jan i.
