[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/COUCHDB-1396?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=13196456#comment-13196456
]
Randall Leeds commented on COUCHDB-1396:
----------------------------------------
This is intended behavior. DELETE is just an update in CouchDB which sets the
new revision to have a {_deleted: true} flag.
If you request
$COUCH/db2/doc?rev=2-f4a2a6b0c7742a5e6dd7eea7a4b625a1&deleted=true you should
see this tombstone update.
Similarly, if you update a non-winning conflict it should return you the new
revision of that branch whether or not it is the winning branch. Updates return
the revision of the update, not the winning revision of the document (in the
case that they are different).
> Deleting a conflict revision will return a wrong current doc revision
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: COUCHDB-1396
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/COUCHDB-1396
> Project: CouchDB
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: Replication
> Reporter: Oliver Kurowski
> Priority: Minor
> Labels: conflict, replication, revision
>
> After deleting the current revision to make the conflict revision the winning
> one,
> the returned revisionnummer ("2-f4a2a6b0c7742a5e6dd7eea7a4b625a1") is not the
> revision number of the documen (1-45c1922c1b51dc5ee945218d63ce2ab4)
> echo $COUCH curly -X
> DELETE $COUCH/db1 curly -X
> DELETE $COUCH/db2 curly -X
> PUT $COUCH/db1
> curly -X PUT $COUCH/db2
> curly -X PUT $COUCH/db1/doc -d '{"wert":1}'
> curly -X PUT $COUCH/db2/doc -d '{"wert":2}'
> curly -X POST $COUCH/_replicate -d '{"source":"db1","target":"db2"}'
> curly $COUCH/db2/doc\?conflicts=true
> curly $COUCH/db2/doc\?revs=true
> curly -X DELETE $COUCH/db2/doc\?rev=1-97cea733330a7b8b41aae9e5732f4ac7
> curly $COUCH/db2/doc\?conflicts=true
> curly $COUCH/db2/doc\?revs=true curly $COUCH/db2/doc
> sendai ~ % echo $COUCH http://localhost:5984
> sendai ~ % curly -X DELETE $COUCH/db1
> { "ok" : true }
> sendai ~ % curly -X DELETE $COUCH/db2
> { "ok" : true }
> sendai ~ % curly -X PUT $COUCH/db1
> { "ok" : true }
> sendai ~ % curly -X PUT $COUCH/db2
> { "ok" : true }
> sendai ~ % curly -X PUT $COUCH/db1/doc -d '{"wert":1}'
> { "ok" : true, "rev" : "1-97cea733330a7b8b41aae9e5732f4ac7", "id" :
> "doc" }
> sendai ~ % curly -X PUT $COUCH/db2/doc -d '{"wert":2}'
> { "ok" : true, "rev" : "1-45c1922c1b51dc5ee945218d63ce2ab4", "id" :
> "doc" }
> sendai ~ % curly -X POST $COUCH/_replicate -d
> '{"source":"db1","target":"db2"}'
> { "ok" : true, "history" : [ { "docs_read" : 1,
> "session_id" : "7c74c9bb9f322e10ad072215e823c2d8", "recorded_seq" :
> 1, "end_last_seq" : 1, "doc_write_failures" : 0,
> "start_time" : "Mon, 30 Jan 2012 20:34:18 GMT", "start_last_seq" :
> 0, "end_time" : "Mon, 30 Jan 2012 20:34:18 GMT",
> "missing_checked" : 0, "docs_written" : 1, "missing_found"
> : 1 } ], "session_id" : "7c74c9bb9f322e10ad072215e823c2d8",
> "source_last_seq" : 1, "replication_id_version" : 2 }
> sendai ~ % curly $COUCH/db2/doc\?conflicts=true
> { "_id" : "doc", "wert" : 1, "_conflicts" : [
> "1-45c1922c1b51dc5ee945218d63ce2ab4" ], "_rev" :
> "1-97cea733330a7b8b41aae9e5732f4ac7" }
> sendai ~ % curly $COUCH/db2/doc\?revs=true
> { "_id" : "doc", "wert" : 1, "_revisions" : { "ids" : [
> "97cea733330a7b8b41aae9e5732f4ac7" ], "start" : 1 },
> "_rev" : "1-97cea733330a7b8b41aae9e5732f4ac7" }
> sendai ~ % curly -X DELETE
> $COUCH/db2/doc\?rev=1-97cea733330a7b8b41aae9e5732f4ac7
> { "ok" : true, "rev" : "2-f4a2a6b0c7742a5e6dd7eea7a4b625a1", "id" :
> "doc" }
>
> ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
> sendai ~ % curly $COUCH/db2/doc\?conflicts=true { "_id" : "doc", "wert"
> : 2, "_rev" : "1-45c1922c1b51dc5ee945218d63ce2ab4" }
> sendai ~ % curly $COUCH/db2/doc\?revs=true { "_id" : "doc", "wert" : 2,
> "_revisions" : { "ids" : [
> "45c1922c1b51dc5ee945218d63ce2ab4" ], "start" : 1 }, "_rev"
> : "1-45c1922c1b51dc5ee945218d63ce2ab4" }
> sendai ~ % curly $COUCH/db2/doc { "_id" : "doc", "wert" : 2, "_rev"
> : "1-45c1922c1b51dc5ee945218d63ce2ab4" }
> sendai ~ %
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
If you think it was sent incorrectly, please contact your JIRA administrators:
https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/ContactAdministrators!default.jspa
For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira
